
A Denver homebuilder that says it has spent more than a decade constructing affordably priced housing is now fighting the city in federal court over the very rules meant to keep homes affordable. redT Homes LLC sued the City of Denver, arguing that its Mandatory Affordable Housing Ordinance — which forces builders to either sell units below market rate or pay a linkage fee — is unconstitutional, and the case reached oral arguments before the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals this week.
Denver's Mandatory Affordable Housing Ordinance, known as MAHO, took effect in 2022, according to the Denver Gazette. Under the program, developers must either pay linkage fees ranging from $1.99 to $7.22 per square foot or set aside 10% of a project to be sold at below-market-rate prices for 99 years, as Courthouse News Service reported. A 2022 Denver City Council bill laid out the compliance options developers could choose from, including providing income-restricted units on-site, paying a fee-in-lieu, or negotiating an alternative arrangement, per Council Bill CB22-0426 on file with Denver City Council.
Fees Add Up Across Smaller Projects
For redT, the costs have landed project by project. The company paid $48,000 in linkage fees — $12,000 per door — on a four-townhome Rosedale project, the Gazette's reporting shows. Those townhomes were initially projected to sell in the $900,000s but are now priced around $809,000, per the same account. Another upcoming redT project will incur $25,000 in fees for four single-family homes, and a separate project will face $45,000 in fees for two duplexes.
redT CEO Nathan Adams told the Gazette the company has been priced out of some projects entirely because of the requirements. He said that when redT began building in 2011, its entry-level homes ran from the high $300,000s to low $400,000s; the current range is $400,000s to $700,000s. Adams said 90% or more of redT's construction over time has been affordably priced housing, even without the mandate.
A Larger Berkeley Project and a Contested Trade-Off
redT is nearing completion on 40 units in the Berkeley neighborhood, north of West 38th Avenue at Perry Street, the Gazette reported. Most of those units are expected to be priced between $550,000 and $750,000, alongside two mandated affordable units Adams expects to price in the low $300,000s. Owners of those below-market units will be limited to a lower rate of future appreciation, a trade-off Adams dismissed as “a disingenuous handout,” the unlinked account notes, since he said owners could benefit while typical homes are depreciating but may lose out on appreciation gains once the market turns. Adams argued that city charges get passed on to buyers while others receive handouts.
A U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado dismissed redT's case at the city's request, ruling that redT failed to state a valid per se physical-taking claim. Denver has argued in the litigation that sales-price limits are not categorically unconstitutional under federal or state law, and that MAHO restricts property use without taking other property interests — the city said in a filing that the ordinance does not violate redT's Fifth Amendment rights against an uncompensated taking, according to the Gazette's report. The Denver City Attorney's office did not respond to the Gazette's request for comment by press time.
Pacific Legal Foundation Takes the Case to Appeal
redT is represented by the Pacific Legal Foundation, which argued before the 10th Circuit on behalf of the company. Lead attorney David Deerson told the Gazette that Denver's affordable-housing system is counterproductive for redT and that the organization believes inclusionary zoning raises home prices and makes homes harder for Denver families to buy, even as the foundation contends redT contributes to alleviating the city's housing shortage. Pacific Legal Foundation has argued that construction permit conditions must be proportional and directly related to a project's impact, citing Supreme Court decisions from 1987 and 1994 holding that governments cannot burden homebuilders with costs for problems they did not create.
Deerson said builders constructing fewer than 10 units will likely choose to pay fees rather than build mandated affordable housing, and he said oral arguments this week went well, with judges engaging on the legal issues and on how the law has shifted. He added that the case's outcome could ripple across the entire 10th Circuit region, covering much of the Rocky Mountain West. The court has not indicated when or how it will rule.
A California Precedent Looms Over the Fight
The legal terrain around inclusionary housing has already been tested once, in California. A 2015 California Supreme Court opinion upheld San Jose's inclusionary-housing ordinance, which required new residential projects of 20 or more units to sell at least 15% of for-sale units at prices affordable to low- or moderate-income households. The court concluded that the conditions San Jose's ordinance imposed on future developments did not constitute takings-clause exactions triggering the unconstitutional-conditions doctrine, according to the opinion. That same ruling noted more than 170 California municipalities had adopted similar inclusionary zoning or housing programs by 2015. The U.S. Supreme Court later overturned a separate California Supreme Court decision in 2023, a shift Deerson has pointed to as part of the changing legal landscape now before the 10th Circuit.









