
A former Denver police recruit who lost both of his legs after a 2023 training exercise asked a federal appeals court this week to revive the lawsuit he filed against the city and the paramedics who treated him. Victor Moses says he disclosed before the drill that he carried sickle cell trait and was at risk of medical complications, only to be cleared to keep going after he grew fatigued and passed out.
Moses was injured on Jan. 6, 2023, during a Denver Police Department training session known as “fight day,” according to Courthouse News Service, which reported that the exercise left him “catastrophically injured and permanently disabled,” in the words of his attorney, David Kilmer. The drill, described by The Washington Post as an eight-minute series of drills simulating an ultra-stressful arrest scenario with multiple assailants, is a mandatory step to becoming a Denver officer, per the same report.
According to Moses's complaint, paramedics measured his blood pressure at 90/60 during the exercise but told him that while his blood pressure was low, he could continue. The complaint, filed by the law firm handling his case, states that “Mr. Moses expressly disclosed that he had sickle cell trait” before the training began.
Hospitalization and Amputation
Moses spent four months in the hospital, where he underwent several surgeries and dialysis, according to his complaint. Both of his legs were amputated below the knee after a drug-resistant infection set in, the complaint states. The Denver Post reported that his complaint alleges aggressive officers knocked him down multiple times during the second round of “fight day” and pressured him to keep going.
Moses sued the City and County of Denver in 2024, naming a dozen paramedics and police officers and alleging that his treatment amounted to excessive force and conscience-shocking government conduct. His lawsuit also alleges that his experience reflected a broader culture of violence and hazing among Denver police recruits, according to USA TODAY — an allegation that has not been independently established in the court record reviewed for this story.
A Case Dismissed, Then Appealed
U.S. District Judge Gordon Gallagher dismissed two of Moses's federal claims in 2025 and remanded his remaining claims to state court. Moses appealed that dismissal, arguing the district judge drew inferences in Denver's favor and did not accept his version of events as true, the Courthouse News report states.
At oral argument this week, Kilmer told the three-judge panel that Denver was effectively asking the court to hold that police recruits have fewer rights than regular citizens and suspected criminals. He also argued that Moses could no longer legally consent to continue training once he had passed out, saying, “Consent is eviscerated at the time that he was knocked out.”
Denver's attorney, Kristin Arthur, argued that the case should be treated as an employment injury rather than a constitutional violation. She told the panel that the injury occurred during a police academy exercise, but that those facts do not change the applicable constitutional standards. Todd Drake, who represents the paramedics and practices at Hershey Decker in Lone Tree, urged the panel to affirm the lower court's dismissal, telling the judges that his clients chose to provide care — a decision he characterized as negligence rather than deliberate indifference. “That is not deliberate indifference, that is negligence,” Drake said.
Judges Press Both Sides
Judge Veronica Rossman questioned why Moses should not have been allowed to continue training when he said he wanted to, while Judge Scott Matheson asked what conduct would constitute an illegal seizure if not the conduct described in this case. Senior U.S. Circuit Judge Timothy Tymkovich also served on the three-judge panel. The court did not indicate when or how it would decide the case, per the Courthouse News account.
A University of South Carolina criminology professor told the Denver Post that the type of training described in the lawsuit is common across the United States and that minor injuries from such drills are common as well. Moses's case remains pending before the 10th Circuit, with no timeline yet for a ruling.









