
Ohio electric customers who were promised refunds for years of unlawful charges could see that money shrink dramatically if Duke Energy and FirstEnergy get their way. The Office of the Ohio Consumers’ Counsel says it will fight back against appeals from the two utilities that could cut an estimated $75 million from refunds already ordered by federal regulators.
The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission ordered Duke Energy and FirstEnergy to refund charges collected since February 2022, with interest, through the date the money is actually returned, according to cleveland.com. Instead of complying with that full window, the utilities are now seeking to limit the refunds to a 15-month period ending in May 2023, per the Consumers’ Counsel.
If that appeal succeeds, the outlet reports it could eliminate roughly three years of refunds for the companies’ Ohio electric customers, totaling an estimated $75 million. Consumers’ Counsel Maureen Willis did not mince words about what is at stake, saying Ohio consumers deserve every dollar they are owed from these unlawful charges, including interest.
A Fight That Started With a 2022 Complaint
The roots of this dispute go back to 2022, when the Consumers’ Counsel filed a complaint with FERC challenging extra profits that Ohio utilities were collecting as an incentive for participating in a regional transmission organization. The watchdog argued utilities should not get a bonus for something Ohio law already requires them to do, since the state mandates participation in these organizations, which function as nonprofits overseeing multi-state power grids.
FERC ultimately ruled in favor of the Consumers’ Counsel. The case didn’t end there: the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit upheld FERC’s decision in January 2025, and the U.S. Supreme Court declined to review the ruling in November 2025, leaving the underlying decision intact. The current appeal from Duke Energy and FirstEnergy, the Consumers’ Counsel says, challenges only the scope of the refunds and does not affect that earlier decision eliminating the charges altogether.
Savings Estimates Separate From the Refund Fight
Beyond the disputed refunds, the Consumers’ Counsel estimates eliminating the charges going forward will save customers of AEP Ohio, Duke Energy Ohio and FirstEnergy hundreds of millions of dollars in future costs. That projection is distinct from the $75 million refund fight now underway, and it echoes an earlier estimate the watchdog made last November, when it projected that removing the so-called RTO adder would save Ohioans more than $400 million through 2031.
The charge at the center of the case was a 0.5% return-on-equity adder on utilities’ transmission investments, a mechanism detailed in cleveland.com's coverage of the Supreme Court's decision not to hear the case. A separate 2022 report from Utility Dive put the value of that incentive at a minimum of $26.5 million a year across Ohio's utilities, underscoring how much money has been flowing through the charge over time.
At the time the Supreme Court declined to hear the case last November, the amount of refunds owed to FirstEnergy and Duke customers for payments made since February 2022 had not yet been calculated, according to cleveland.com's reporting from that period. Willis said the Consumers’ Counsel will fight to ensure Duke Energy and FirstEnergy return the money to the consumers who paid the charges in the first place, regardless of how the latest appeal plays out.









