
The Eagle Urban Renewal Agency has formally offered $1.6 million to buy the historic Orville Jackson House and the land beneath it, pushing the 1932 Tudor-style landmark toward a new chapter after years of city ownership. The Eagle City Council voted Tuesday night to accept a letter of intent for the property at 127 S. Eagle Road, though that vote is not evidence the transfer has actually closed.
According to Idaho Statesman, council members Craig Kvamme and Mary May voted in favor of the letter of intent, Councilman Robert Gillis voted against it, and Mayor Brad Pike and Nancy Merrill both abstained. The split vote reflects a debate that has simmered since the city first bought the property in 2021 with an eye toward preserving it.
The Idaho Statesman reports the city paid $2.1 million for the house that year, while a separate Idaho Statesman article put the 2021 purchase price at $2 million; a lower-confidence account from BoiseDev cited $2.05 million. The discrepancy has not been resolved publicly. What is clear is that the house, built in 1932 and described in the city's own historic inventory as a one-and-a-half-story Tudoresque residence, has carried significant costs for the city to maintain, a point council members have cited in weighing whether Eagle should continue owning it.
Facade Protections and a View Corridor
As part of the letter of intent, the council added a historic facade easement requiring whoever ends up owning the house to maintain its exterior according to preservation standards. The easement would prohibit demolition outright and heavily regulate any alterations to the structure, the station's report notes. City leaders are also weighing restrictions on tall fences, dense tree lines and other structures that could block the house's view from Eagle Road, building in protections beyond the deed restrictions already on the books.
The house is one of seven Eagle properties listed on the National Register of Historic Places, having earned that designation in 1982, per the same Idaho Statesman reporting. Existing deed restrictions already bar the house from being moved or demolished, but the urban renewal agency is adding conditions meant to shore up those protections further, including keeping the area between Eagle Road and the house free of new development so the structure stays visible from the street.
A 60-Day Window for Developers
Once the agency formally issues requests for proposals, developers will have 60 days to submit their ideas for the property, the article notes. Mark Butler, chairman of the Eagle Urban Renewal Agency, said the agency has already been in talks with one developer group, though multiple parties have expressed interest in the site. Any development is expected to occur on portions of the property behind the house, with potential uses including parking, residential development, or other projects vetted through a public process.
Butler has said preservation, not profit, is the agency's driving goal for the property, and that the house stands as one of the few remaining physical connections to Eagle's past. He also noted his own three-decade acquaintance with Shari Sharp, who lived in the house at the time the city purchased it.
A Future Roadway Looms Over the Deal
The letter of intent retains language tying the sale to progress on a future roadway, and Butler called an agreement supporting that road a potential deal killer if it fails to advance, according to Idaho Statesman. That condition has become a flashpoint on the council, since any new roadway near the property would intersect with downtown Eagle's already tight traffic and parking footprint.
Gillis, who cast the lone vote against Tuesday's action, has said the property already carries deed restrictions and a historical landmark designation, arguing the city does not need to own it to keep its character intact. He supports selling the property and removing it from the city's books, but opposes doing so under the conditions currently attached to the letter of intent. Gillis has raised concerns that additional roads could worsen downtown Eagle traffic, that a road to the plaza could eat into parking and affect the drive-through at a nearby Walgreens pharmacy, and that part of a parking lot could face eminent domain while commercial development rises behind the house on Old Park Place.
The city council previously voted to sell the home rather than continue holding it, a decision shaped by workshops and joint meetings between the council and the urban renewal agency that produced the purchase and sales framework now in motion. Proposals for the property are due January 6, according to Butler, after which an agency committee will review submissions before a vetting process and final selection. Butler has said groundbreaking is not expected for roughly a year and a half or longer once a developer is chosen.









