
Esney Davis-Sharpe, a 63-year-old East Orange resident, was sentenced to 180 days in county jail for health care claims fraud and related crimes involving medical services provided without a license.
She admitted the gynecological care was unlicensed, and that claims for it went out under licensed physicians’ names. Attorney General Jennifer Davenport and the Office of the Insurance Fraud Prosecutor announced the sentence on Nov. 16. The case centers on Bessie Mae Women’s Health Center, the women’s and family practice Davis-Sharpe owned and operated in East Orange. The New Jersey Attorney General’s office described the county jail term as six months’ imprisonment.
What She Pleaded Guilty To
Davis-Sharpe pleaded guilty before Superior Court Judge Michael Ravin to second-degree health care claims fraud, third-degree Medicaid fraud, and third-degree unlicensed practice of medicine.
The second-degree count is the health care claims fraud. The third-degree counts are Medicaid fraud and unlicensed practice of medicine. Those counts track what she admitted: gynecological care without a license, and claims filed under licensed doctors’ names.
Davenport said the sentence holds Davis-Sharpe accountable for unlicensed medical services and fraudulent billing. Bernard J. Cooney said she circumvented safeguards by performing unlicensed medical services and submitting claims under licensed physicians’ names.
The announcement treats her as an Essex County defendant. She lives in East Orange, and the clinic operated there. The office reported the punishment as 180 days in county jail. The headline on the release calls that term six months’ imprisonment.
Care She Was Not Licensed to Give
Bessie Mae Women’s Health Center offered obstetrics and gynecology, primary care, and family care services. On that list, it was a women’s and family health practice. The owner’s admission was narrower than the menu.
She admitted she performed gynecological services on patients at Bessie Mae without a medical license. She admitted she submitted insurance claims under licensed doctors’ names for services she rendered without being licensed. She also admitted submitting claims to New Jersey Medicaid under licensed doctors’ names for services she improperly rendered.
Submitting those claims under licensed physicians’ names was, in Cooney’s account, how she circumvented safeguards around unlicensed care. The gynecological services, she admitted, were hers. The license on the paperwork was not.
Approximately 2,500 Medicaid Claims
Investigators alleged a much longer paper trail than one owner’s admission. Between December 2020 and February 2024, approximately 2,500 Medicaid reimbursement claims were submitted on behalf of the practice, RLS Media reported.
Those claims allegedly listed licensed physicians without their knowledge or consent for services that were actually performed by unlicensed individuals. The figure covers more than three years of Medicaid billing alleged on behalf of the East Orange practice.
December 2020 to February 2024 is the investigators’ window, not a single billing cycle. It runs through the August 2023 referral and past the January 2024 cease-and-desist, and it is the period they tie to those approximately 2,500 claims.
A Referral, Then an Order to Stop
The New Jersey Division of Consumer Affairs referred the matter to the Office of the Insurance Fraud Prosecutor in August 2023 for investigation of unlicensed practice at Bessie Mae. Consumer Affairs had the license question. The fraud office had the bills.
By then, the alleged Medicaid billing window had already been open since December 2020, more than two and a half years. The Department of Health did not serve its cease-and-desist until Jan. 25, 2024, about five months after the referral. That order, served on Davis-Sharpe, directed Bessie Mae to stop providing services at the facility immediately.
The alleged claims don’t stop on the date of the order. Investigators say Medicaid reimbursement claims were submitted on behalf of the practice as late as February 2024. The jail sentence was announced on Nov. 16, more than two years after the Department of Health ordered the center to stop.
The Unit That Brought the Case
Sean O’Connor and Lauren Aranguren prosecuted the case for the Medicaid Fraud Control Unit in the Office of the Insurance Fraud Prosecutor. Regina Strugala and Chantel Blake led the investigation.
The announcement also sets out the unit’s expected funding for federal fiscal year 2027, $12.9 million in all. The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services awarded $9.7 million in grant funding, equal to 75 percent of that expected total. New Jersey funds the other $3.2 million, or 25 percent.
The Office of the Insurance Fraud Prosecutor can be contacted at (609) 292-1272 or [email protected].









