Minneapolis/ Politics & Govt

Education Department Probes Teacher-Prep Programs in Three States

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 17, 2026
Education Department Probes Teacher-Prep Programs in Three StatesMinnesota Department of Education — Administers Tuition Assistance Program
Google Street View

The U.S. Department of Education has opened civil rights investigations into teacher-preparation programs in New York, Maryland and Minnesota, focusing on recruitment, support and financial help tied to race or sex.

The inquiries, opened Nov. 13, allege race discrimination under Title VI or sex discrimination under Title IX. They follow a year in which the department canceled most of its Teacher Quality Partnership and Supporting Effective Educator Development grants, then lost the directive it used to do it. The department said the Office for Civil Rights is acting on credible reports that several institutions "provide sex or race-specific recruitment, support, and financial opportunities for candidates in violation of civil rights laws."

What the Civil Rights Office Says It Is Investigating

Assistant Secretary for Civil Rights Kimberly Richey said race, national origin or sex should not decide who shapes the next generation. She said many states and universities seem to prioritize "recruiting and training 'minority' candidates rather than evaluating candidates based solely on merit," Inside Higher Ed reported. She also said institutions that use race, national origin or sex to withhold opportunities in selecting, supporting and preparing teaching candidates violate federal law and compromise educational excellence, and that students should be judged on hard work and merit rather than prejudged by skin color or sex.

The programs named in the inquiries include CUNY's NYC Men Teach; the University of Maryland School of Education and the Maryland Higher Education Commission's Teacher Quality and Diversity Grant Program; and, in Minnesota, the Education Tuition Assistance Program, administered by the state Education Department, and the Aspiring Teachers of Color Scholarship Pilot Program, administered by the Minnesota Office of Higher Education. Inside Higher Ed described Maryland's grant program as intended "to assist students from groups historically underrepresented in the teaching profession," and Minnesota's tuition-assistance mission as including an effort to "increase the number of teacher candidates of color and American Indian candidates."

The department's theory treats a demographic goal in recruitment or aid as the civil rights violation. The programs, as their own pages and the statutes behind them describe them, treat that same goal as the point of the money. Those are not yet findings. They are the two descriptions OCR has put in the same file.

A New York Pipeline and a Goal the City Already Counted

NYC Men Teach is a partnership involving the Mayor's Office, New York City Public Schools and CUNY. The aim was to add 1,000 men of color to New York City's teacher pipeline. CUNY says the program surpassed that goal by 2018 and provides academic and financial support to about 600 participants each year.

CUNY says the activities are "open to all eligible applicants, without regard to race, gender, national origin or other characteristic protected by law." It told K-12 Dive the same thing about NYC Men Teach and its related programs. The recruitment goal published beside that sentence is narrower than the eligibility line. The same federal department that helped launch the effort in 2015 is now the office asking whether the effort breaks the law.

Maryland's Grants and a Minnesota Statute

Maryland's piece of the inquiry is a state grant program described as support for preparation programs serving students historically underrepresented in teaching, plus the University of Maryland School of Education. The public descriptions stop at that purpose. They do not, in the reporting now available from the institutions themselves, spell out a point system or a closed applicant pool.

Minnesota is more explicit because the legislature wrote the goal into statute. The state Education Department says it has funding under Minnesota Statutes, section 122A.635, for public or private institutions with a Professional Educator Licensing and Standards Board-approved program "to increase the number of teacher candidates of color and American Indian candidates recommended for Tier 3 licensure across the state, for the benefit of all Minnesota students."

Section 122A.635 tells the department to award competitive grants to increase the number of teacher candidates of color or who are American Indian, who finish preparation programs, and who meet the requirements for a Tier 3 license under section 122A.183. The Aspiring Teachers of Color Scholarship Pilot Program is a separate Minnesota initiative also named in the federal inquiries. Section 122A.635 directs the tuition-assistance grants toward that increase. OCR is asking whether that kind of direction is the discrimination.

Last Year's Cuts, and a Directive a Judge Vacated

These investigations are a different action from the grant cancellations, and the court case over those cancellations does not decide them. The sequence still matters to anyone trying to fund a preparation program. In February 2025 the department directed staff to review new awards and grants already issued so federal money would not support what it called discriminatory practices, including DEI. It then terminated awards under Supporting Effective Educator Development, Teacher Quality Partnership, and Teacher and School Leader Incentive programs, citing the promotion of divisive ideologies.

By March 12, 2025, the department had terminated 104 of 109 TQP and SEED grants under that directive, including 40 in the states that later sued, according to a summary-judgment ruling in the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts. Inside Higher Ed reported that the department terminated more than $600 million in educator-training grants in 2025. JURIST put the canceled TQP and SEED grants at about $600 million. Those are overlapping descriptions, not the same pile: the court figure is limited to TQP and SEED.

On Sept. 17, 2026, the court vacated and set aside the February 2025 directive in its entirety. It found the directive gave no discernible criteria for "DEI," and that the department was required to use notice-and-comment rulemaking under the General Education Provisions Act.

In the grant case, Judge Kelley said completions of traditional teacher-preparation programs had fallen 35% in the prior decade, and that nearly 300,000 teachers leave the profession each year.

Merit, Shortages and a Wider Enforcement Pattern

The workforce those programs were written against is not a secret. In the 2020–21 school year, roughly 80% of teachers in public K–12 schools were white, 6% were Black and 9% were Hispanic, Inside Higher Ed reported. The American Association of Colleges for Teacher Education said a diverse educator pipeline is essential to persistent shortages and to putting well-prepared, effective teachers in classrooms, and that research finds a diverse workforce benefits students academically, socially and emotionally. The association does not comment on active federal inquiries involving specific institutions or state agencies.

Colleges have already watched a similar inquiry change behavior. In 2025 the department opened investigations into 45 colleges connected to the PhD Project; by February 2026, Inside Higher Ed reported, 31 of them had ended their partnerships with the nonprofit.

The programs on OCR's list are preparation scholarships and recruitment efforts in three states. Minnesota's section 122A.635 directs competitive tuition-assistance grants to increase the number of candidates of color and American Indian candidates who finish preparation and qualify for a Tier 3 license.