
Ellen Morrison Kelley lost her bid for Floyd County commissioner by just 152 votes, and now she wants a judge to decide whether that outcome should stand. On Tuesday, she filed a petition in Floyd County Circuit Court seeking a special election after an early-voting ballot error left the District 1 commissioner race off ballots in four precincts.
The petition, filed by Morrison Kelley and her legal team, asks the court to schedule a hearing within 20 days, according to WHAS11. No judge has yet been assigned to the case. Morrison Kelley, the Democratic challenger, faced Republican incumbent Al Knable in a race that came down to 27,816 total votes cast between them.
How the Ballot Error Unfolded
The trouble traces back to early October, when the Floyd County Election Board discovered that ballots in the Franklin, Greenville, Georgetown and Lafayette precincts had omitted the District 1 commissioner contest entirely. According to lpm.org, officials identified 572 impacted voters, a group that included people who voted early in person between Oct. 6 and Oct. 8 as well as absentee voters.
Election officials said the programming error was corrected and that early voting resumed Oct. 9 with fixed ballot styles loaded onto the voting machines, per the same report. Affected voters were told they would receive a written explanation along with an ABS-5 form, followed by instructions on how to cast a corrected ballot. New Albany voters were not affected by the error, and the mistake was fixed within three days.
A Race Decided by 152 Votes
The stakes of that glitch come into focus against the final tally. Knable won with 13,984 votes, or 50.27%, to Morrison Kelley's 13,832 votes, or 49.73%, according to the News and Tribune. Only 152 votes separated the two candidates in a race where 27,816 people cast ballots.
Morrison Kelley claims that roughly 300 voters never got the chance to vote in the race at all. She has also questioned whether all 572 affected voters received proper notice that their original ballots were incomplete, according to WHAS11's report. She said she wants an election day held in the four affected townships.
Candidates Stake Out Their Positions
Morrison Kelley has framed her petition as a matter of principle rather than a bid to overturn the outcome in her favor. She told WHAS11 that her challenge was about giving all voters the chance to cast a ballot, rather than about who won, adding that the right to vote and have that vote counted is fundamental and had not happened in Floyd County.
Knable, for his part, said he understood and respected the procedures for scrutinizing election outcomes and that he would participate in the proceedings while hoping for a timely resolution, per the same WHAS11 account. He said he was pleased the Floyd County Election Board unanimously certified the Nov. 3 election results the week before Morrison Kelley's filing, and in an earlier interview he acknowledged the ballot error also affected his own results.
Not an Isolated Glitch in Indiana
Floyd County's mix-up echoes a similar dispute playing out in Tippecanoe County, where a voting-machine error left hundreds of early voters without the option to vote for a Democratic candidate in a township trustee race. The Tippecanoe County Democratic Party chairman said the party planned to petition for its own special election, according to the Purdue Exponent.
In that case, the error kept candidate Holden Mugford's name off voting machines for 13 days, from Oct. 9 through Oct. 21, affecting 424 voters. Of those, 117 managed to cast corrected ballots before the Nov. 2 deadline and another 74 straight-ticket Democratic votes were properly credited to Mugford, leaving 233 ballots still in question, the Purdue Exponent reported.
Back in Floyd County, the 572 affected voters amount to a notable share of the electorate in a commissioner race that typically draws around 26,000 votes, based on turnout four years earlier, according to hoosierenquirer.com. Overall turnout in this year's general election was also down sharply, with just 44.65% of registered voters casting ballots compared to 66.21% in the 2024 general election, per soinformed812.substack.com.
No hearing date has been set in the Floyd County case, and it remains unclear how many of the 572 affected voters ultimately filled out the ABS-5 form or returned to cast a corrected ballot. For now, the race between Morrison Kelley and Knable sits in legal limbo while both sides await the court's next move.









