
A former Alamance County sheriff's sergeant wants a federal judge to look at what he says was happening inside mandatory training: exam answers left where deputies could use them, and confidential case material turned into coworker entertainment. Michael Shane Apple says he reported it. He also says the office then took his rank, cut his pay and, months later, ended the job.
The Burlington Times-News reported that Apple, who worked about 12 years at the Alamance County Sheriff's Office, filed the lawsuit in U.S. District Court for the Middle District of North Carolina. As the paper describes the complaint, he alleges deputies rampantly cheated on mandatory annual training and testing and that supervisors encouraged it. Those claims are allegations.
Answers left out, files recut
The lawsuit alleges that patrol lieutenants cheated on in-service examinations and that the answers were posted publicly for deputies to use. It further alleges that multiple lieutenants endorsed the cheating openly. Apple says that in 2025 he reported wholesale cheating on the agency's mandatory annual in-service training and testing.
The complaint's sharper allegation is not about a quiz. It says one lieutenant used confidential investigatory information, active criminal-case information, grand-jury-secrecy materials and investigatory-file video to make entertainment reels that circulated among coworkers. Grand-jury material is supposed to stay quiet. In the lawsuit's telling, some of it became office programming.
Apple's suit alleges he was disciplined, demoted and transferred for reporting and documenting that cheating and the misuse of confidential investigative information by agency leadership.
Sergeant one year, Deputy III the next
The office demoted Apple from sergeant to deputy and placed him on probation on October 17, 2025, cutting his pay by more than $7,500. Alamance News reported a demotion on October 17, 2025, with a pay reduction of $7,563.60. Same direction, two dates.
The lawsuit also says Apple was accused in August 2025 of falsifying work hours. He said he did not knowingly misreport his time. The complaint describes two complaints against him from an anonymous email account. The second, it says, involved a January 2026 social-media post about someone at a public park. The Times-News account says he was on medical leave after a work injury when he made that post, and that he said he was given no chance to explain it, answer the charge or offer anything in mitigation.
The same lawsuit alleges that other sheriff's office employees made social-media posts that violated department policy, including posts with inflammatory content, and were not fired. Alamance News reported that the office dismissed Apple on February 2, 2026, when he was a Deputy III earning $78,976.36. The Times-News reported that a second complaint, concerning a January 2026 social-media post, was the basis for his firing.
A $625,000 lesson in counting hours
Timekeeping was already an expensive subject at the office. In January, the sheriff's office agreed to pay $625,000 to settle a class-action lawsuit over how it calculated work hours and overtime, the Times-News reported. The settlement concerned the office's calculation of work hours and overtime.
Alamance News, in a May 1, 2026, report updated and corrected July 9, 2026, said the sheriff's office had enforced 22 disciplinary actions against 19 staff members over the preceding year and a half, including seven dismissals. Apple was among those dismissed during that period.
The new suit seeks unspecified damages of more than $25,000. What it puts in front of a judge, still untested, is a former sergeant's account of posted exam answers, case files recut as reels, and a pay cut of $7,563.60 on the way out of a job that had lasted about 14 years and two months.









