
Patricia Kimble was a 28-year-old Sunday school teacher found in the burning remains of her Pleasant Garden home with a gunshot wound to her head, a killing that shattered a community in Guilford County that had recorded only two other homicides in the preceding 100 years. More than two decades later, her husband and the brother-in-law who investigators say pulled the trigger both remain behind bars.
A Fire, a Reward, and a Husband Under Suspicion
On Oct. 9, 1995, Patricia had left work early to do yard work before church, according to Greensboro News and Record. Firefighters arrived to find her home fully engulfed, and the same reporting says an autopsy later determined her cause of death was a gunshot wound to the side of her head, a finding also laid out in the North Carolina Court of Appeals opinion on the case, per State v. Kimble. Investigators concluded the fire had been set deliberately, ruling it arson, the same court record states.
Ted Kimble, Patricia's husband, offered a $20,000 reward to find her killer in the weeks after her death, and told investigators in November 1995 that he did not trust local deputies because they had suggested he was involved, the Greensboro paper reports. Prosecutors later alleged at trial that Ted had forged Patricia's name on a $200,000 life insurance policy shortly before her death and spent extravagantly afterward, including, investigators said, buying a motorcycle with church money collected for her funeral expenses.
The Brother Who Became a Suspect
Ted had proposed to Patricia in 1993, and the couple had been married two years when she was killed. Authorities turned their investigation toward Ted after ruling the fire an arson, and his younger brother, Ronnie Kimble, a U.S. Marine, soon became a suspect as well. Per investigators, Ronnie was the only person Ted could trust, and at trial investigators said Ted had hired Ronnie to shoot Patricia and burn her body. The case was ultimately solved by investigator Jim Church working alongside State Bureau of Investigation Agent Harold Pendergrass, according to the Greensboro News and Record's account.
Both brothers faced the death penalty in connection with Patricia's death. Ronnie was tried first, with his trial taking place roughly three years after the killing. A jury found Ronnie Lee Kimble guilty of first-degree murder, conspiracy to commit murder and first-degree arson, according to the court opinion in State v. Kimble, and he was sentenced to life in prison. The same opinion notes that Ted invoked his Fifth Amendment privilege and did not testify at his brother's trial, and that the state had argued Ted recruited Ronnie to carry out the killing.
Falwell's Secret Testimony and the Student Who Came Forward
One of the trial's most startling moments came from an unlikely witness: the Rev. Jerry Falwell. According to the Greensboro News and Record, Falwell testified after a seminary student came to him distraught, having heard Ronnie Kimble's alleged murder confession, and the newspaper reports that Falwell's testimony had been kept secret before it was revealed in court.
Ted Kimble later pleaded guilty to Patricia's murder, after maintaining his innocence for years, and a judge sentenced him to at least 107 years in prison. The Greensboro paper also reported that Ted faced separate charges of hiring an inmate to kill eight potential witnesses against him. Today, both brothers remain in prison, the paper notes.
From Courtroom to True-Crime Bestseller
The case drew national attention well beyond the Guilford County courtroom. Author Lynn Chandler Willis, who covered the trial as a reporter, spent dozens of hours after the verdict interviewing detectives, firefighters, friends and relatives, and reviewed crime scene photos and Patricia's diary while researching what became her book, Unholy Covenant. Willis has written that she sat through every single day of Ronnie's six-week trial, and has described the case as one involving a husband who hired his brother to kill his wife with the promise of a share of a life insurance policy; both Willis's account and Oxygen's reporting give the policy amount as $200,000.
Willis had a book contract before the trial even ended, and Unholy Covenant went on to reach No. 1 on three Amazon lists and received a second printing. The case was later adapted for reenactment television, with Oxygen and other networks featuring the story. Oxygen's account states that Ronnie confessed to an associate named Mitch Whidden in January 1997, telling him he killed Patricia at Ted's request because Ted wanted the insurance money, and that the Kimble brothers were arrested on April 1, 1997 and jailed separately in hopes one would break and confess.









