
More than a decade after Jim Johnson Jr. vanished from an Orange County barbershop and turned up dead in the woods near Daytona Beach, four men are now behind bars, accused in connection with his kidnapping and killing. Carlton Williams, 50, Sean Davis, 35, Nathaniel Webster, 42, and Derrick Dean, 47, each face a first-degree murder charge along with a string of other felonies tied to the 2013 case.
According to WESH 2 News, all four men are being held without bond at the Volusia County Jail. Investigators say Johnson, 39, was kidnapped from Goolies Barbershop on Orange Blossom Trail on December 6, 2013, a detail WESH 2 News attributes to investigators in its earlier reporting on the case. That abduction, per the arrest records, was connected to a home invasion at Johnson's mother's Orlando home later that same morning.
Per the affidavit described by the station, Williams is accused of orchestrating the fatal kidnapping, while Davis, Dean and Webster are described as having auxiliary roles. The document, reportedly more than 200 pages long, states that the men's coordinated actions and communications demonstrated shared intent and active participation in the felonies that led to Johnson's death. It further states that each participant knowingly aided, encouraged, or assisted in the offenses and was criminally responsible as a principal or co-conspirator under Florida law.
A Trail That Led From Orlando to Daytona Beach
Accounts of the days that followed Johnson's disappearance vary slightly between sources. WESH 2 News has reported that detectives found Johnson's white Cadillac at an Orlando-area apartment complex off Hiawassee Road three days after the kidnapping, on December 9, 2013.
WESH 2 News has reported that a passerby discovered Johnson's decomposing body in woods off South Beach Street in Daytona Beach two days after the Cadillac turned up, on December 11, 2013. The medical examiner reported no signs of trauma on Johnson's body, and his death was ruled a homicide, though WESH 2 News has reported that how it happened remained unknown.
Charges Span Murder, Kidnapping and Racketeering
Each of the four defendants faces serious charges beyond first-degree murder, including two counts of grand theft of a motor vehicle, burglary with assault or battery involving a firearm, aggravated battery with a firearm, unlawful use of a two-way communication device, and a RICO charge. Davis, Webster and Williams each face two kidnapping counts; Dean faces one kidnapping count and a separate kidnapping-with-a-firearm charge. Davis, Dean and Webster also face armed robbery with a firearm or deadly weapon; Williams faces robbery with a firearm. Dean also faces an out-of-county warrant.
Florida law draws a sharp line between degrees of murder that could become relevant as the case proceeds. Under Florida Statutes § 782.04, first-degree murder is classified as a capital felony.
A Decade of Waiting for Johnson's Family
For years, the case sat unresolved. WESH 2 News previously quoted a family member saying, “it's been ten years and we haven't had any arrests and no conviction,” underscoring just how long Johnson's relatives waited for movement in the investigation. The outlet's earlier coverage also noted that Johnson was last seen that Friday morning at the barbershop, a detail also reported by News 13 in the days after he disappeared.
WESH 2 News says it plans to continue reviewing the voluminous court documents in the case and will update its reporting as new details emerge. No trial dates or additional case details beyond the charges and arrests have been reported.









