
A federal judge has dismissed a six-year challenge by four of Oklahoma’s largest tribal nations to gaming compacts Gov. Kevin Stitt signed in 2020. U.S. District Judge Timothy Kelly ruled that the Cherokee Nation, Chickasaw Nation, Choctaw Nation and Citizen Potawatomi Nation had not established standing to sue. The decision leaves unresolved whether the compacts comply with federal gaming law.
The case concerned agreements Stitt signed in April 2020 with the Comanche Nation and the Otoe-Missouria Tribe of Indians. They authorized house-banked card and table games and sports betting—wagering types the four plaintiff tribes argued were not legal under Oklahoma law, according to The Journal Record. The plaintiffs said the compacts were invalid under the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act, which requires compacts to be legally entered into by both parties. Then-Interior Secretary David Bernhardt allowed the agreements to take effect in 2020 by taking no action on them, a mechanism provided under federal law.
Kelly's ruling did not decide whether the compacts actually complied with federal gaming law. Instead, he found the tribes' claimed economic injury — the prospect of new competition from the Comanche Nation and Otoe-Missouria Tribe — was speculative. The judge wrote that the plaintiffs had failed to show they suffered a redressable injury in fact, and that any harm tied to future competition or a change in state law was, in his words, simply too attenuated and speculative to support competitor standing, per the same report.
Casinos That Haven't Been Built
Central to the case were provisions allowing for up to six potential new casinos, with the compacts promising the governor's support for taking land into trust for as many as three new facilities for each tribe. But Kelly found that outcome was far from imminent. Construction of any new casino depends on land being taken into trust first, and that process requires the consent of the U.S. Secretary of the Interior, has not begun, and would likely face its own legal challenge, the judge noted.
The compacts also set new exclusivity fee rates and require quarterly reports to the Oklahoma Office of Management and Enterprise Services, provisions that remain in place regardless of Kelly’s ruling. The Oklahoma Office of Management and Enterprise Services reported that the state collected over $191.5 million in tribal gaming exclusivity fees in fiscal year 2022; that figure is state fee revenue, not tribal gaming revenue.
Drummond's Role in the Fight
Oklahoma Attorney General Gentner Drummond filed a friend-of-the-court brief backing the four plaintiff tribes, arguing Stitt lacked the actual authority to bind the state when he signed the Comanche and Otoe-Missouria compacts. That argument echoed a separate ruling — referred to in filings as the Treat 1 decision — which found Stitt exceeded his authority by signing compacts allowing gaming prohibited under state law.
A Separate State-Law Ruling
The federal standing dismissal is distinct from the Oklahoma Supreme Court’s July 21, 2020, decision in Treat v. Stitt. The court ruled that Stitt lacked authority under Oklahoma law to bind the state to the Comanche and Otoe-Missouria compacts, according to the Oklahoma Supreme Court decision, reproduced by Justia. That state-law ruling did not resolve the federal question Kelly left undecided: whether the compacts comply with federal gaming law.
Drummond's involvement reflects a broader rift between his office and the governor over who controls the state's legal position on tribal gaming. That tension has also surfaced at the Oklahoma Supreme Court, which was asked in a certified question whether the attorney general could take control of the state's defense over the governor's objection when the governor had already hired his own counsel; the court answered that question in the negative, according to the Oklahoma Supreme Court.
A Pattern of Compact Disputes
This case is far from the only compact fight playing out in Oklahoma. The Cherokee, Chickasaw and Choctaw nations separately filed a federal lawsuit seeking a declaration that their own gaming compacts had renewed under their existing terms, as KOCO reported. Two other tribes, the Kialegee Tribal Town and the United Keetoowah Band of Cherokee Indians, instead signed an eight-month gaming extension with the state rather than pursue litigation. Oklahoma voters first approved a state question allowing casino-style gambling back in 2004, laying the legal foundation for the tribal gaming industry that has since become a major source of friction between the state and tribal governments.
Accounts of exactly when Kelly issued his underlying summary judgment ruling differ slightly: a law firm, Crowe & Dunlevy, dated the decision to September 21, 2026, while Law360 reported the ruling came September 22, 2026. Both accounts agree on the substance: Kelly granted summary judgment to the federal and tribal defendants after finding the four nations failed to establish standing.
The Journal Record reported it reached out to the Cherokee Nation for comment but had not received a response by publication time. The case leaves unresolved the underlying question of whether the Comanche and Otoe-Missouria compacts comply with federal gaming law, since Kelly's dismissal turned entirely on standing rather than the merits.









