Fairfield County/ Politics & Govt

Greenwich School Board Feud Reignites Over $700K Lawsuit Days Before Chair Vote

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 15, 2026
Greenwich School Board Feud Reignites Over $700K Lawsuit Days Before Chair VoteSource: Michael D Beckwith / Unsplash

Greenwich First Selectman Fred Camillo says a November 9 meeting with two Board of Education members produced a positive framework for potentially resolving a lawsuit that has dragged on for roughly two years, but acting board chair Sophie Koven is cautioning that nothing is settled yet. The renewed sparring comes just days before the school board is expected to select new officers at its Thursday, November 19 meeting.

Camillo and Koven Describe the Same Meeting Differently

Camillo said he had positive discussions with board member Paul Cappiali and acting chair Koven about resolving the litigation, and told Patch their November 9 sit-down had established a positive framework for potentially resolving the lawsuit. Koven, for her part, called the conversation a very productive one and said she left feeling optimistic. But she was also careful to note the limits of what she could promise: as one member of an eight-member board, she said, she could not commit the board to any agreement terms, and the board will vote in public on any proposed agreement. Camillo said the one thing the two did not resolve during that meeting was the matter of legal fees already charged.

Camillo has said he remains hopeful an agreement will be reached and ultimately approved by the full Board of Education, framing the lawsuit as something that was brought only after the other side threatened to sue him and ignored state law. He also said he wants acknowledgment of what happened and assurances that it would not happen again. He has said his attorney fees have been paid, though by whom was not specified.

Democrats Put a Price Tag on the Fight

The dispute over cost has become its own flashpoint. The Greenwich Democratic Town Committee said the litigation has already cost taxpayers more than $700,000, and estimated that figure could climb to a staggering $1.2 million once a proposed $500,000 in 2027 legal expenses is factored in, according to the Greenwich Democratic Town Committee. That $500,000 figure appears in the Board of Education's proposed budget for increased legal expenses in 2027, per the same Patch report. The Greenwich superintendent had proposed an operating budget including that figure for attorney fees, and the board has said it has funds available for legal expenses within its appropriated budget, even though the Town of Greenwich has not released the board's legal-expense funds.

Camillo pushed back hard on the Democrats' framing, saying the committee's statement contained lies and sought to deceive residents, and writing that the DTC's claims threaten to disrupt a possible BOE lawsuit agreement. He also said the DTC was undermining the efforts of both Koven and Cappiali. DTC chair Christina Downey said the organization stands by its November 12 newsletter, and according to the dossier, Downey also said Camillo can withdraw the case unilaterally as plaintiff.

Conflicting Trial Dates Still Unresolved

The trial schedule remains unclear: one account gives April 20, 2027, while another gives August 10, 2027.

The legal fight has already produced plenty of twists at the negotiating table. The board voted unanimously, 8-0, on May 28, 2026, to authorize its counsel to enter settlement negotiations with the town. A subsequent vote to settle the matter failed in June, and a separate account of the board's June 22 meeting described a motion to accept a settlement offer in Camillo v. Hirsch tying 4-4 and failing, after which the board voted 8-0 to direct its attorneys to resume expedited talks, according to citizenportal.ai. As of the end of March, $192,644 in First Selectman legal fees had been paid out of the law department's budget, while $304,002 in Board of Education legal fees had been invoiced but not paid, per the Free Press report.

Roots of the Dispute Trace Back to a 2024 Vacancy

The underlying fight traces back to October 21, 2024, when the school board voted 4-1 at an emergency meeting to appoint Republican Jen Behette to a vacant seat. The Board of Selectmen appointed Republican Paul Cappiali to the same vacancy the following day, setting up the clash that led to litigation. Connecticut's Freedom of Information Commission later found that the board's emergency meeting was improperly noticed, did not constitute an emergency, and that its actions were null and void, per the same Patch report.

Cappiali was ultimately elected to the board on November 4, 2025, and sworn in at a November 20, 2025 meeting. He went on to become chair of the Republican Town Committee in April 2026. Koven became acting chair after board member Michael-Joseph Mercanti-Anthony resigned; he and fellow member Wendy Vizzo Walsh both stepped down over the summer, with Jonathan Katz and Jeffrey Csoka later selected to fill those seats, according to the seed reporting from Greenwich Free Press.

The Greenwich Board of Education currently has eight members, split evenly between four Republicans and four Democrats, meaning the board needs five votes out of eight to elect a chair. Neither a tie vote nor a four-to-three vote with one abstention would satisfy that requirement. The board must hold officer elections within 30 calendar days of its regular November meeting. If the board fails to elect a chair by its deadline, the Board of Selectmen determines who takes the post, as happened in 2024 when the Board of Selectmen voted 2-1 to select Karen Kowalski. Board of Education officer terms last one year.