Greenville/ Crime & Emergencies

Greenwood County Man Gets 30 Years for Hunting Down and Killing Stepson

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 20, 2026
Greenwood County Man Gets 30 Years for Hunting Down and Killing Stepson600 Monument St — Greenwood County Case Setting
Google Street View

A Greenwood County man will spend 30 years in prison after a jury convicted him of killing his mentally ill adult stepson, following an eight-day trial that laid out how a family argument escalated into a fatal shooting. William Morgan, 36, admitted during an interview with investigators that he killed 29-year-old Caleb Donnelly, telling them he did it to put Donnelly “out of his misery.”

According to WYFF, the violence traces back to June 2021, when Morgan got into a domestic dispute with Donnelly. The clash began at a party at another home before spilling back to Morgan's own property, where Donnelly damaged property inside the house. Deputies responded and attempted to de-escalate the situation rather than making an immediate arrest.

Deputies Gave Family Time Before Tragedy Struck

Per the station's report, deputies told Donnelly's mother they could obtain an arrest warrant for her son. Prosecutors said this was presumably intended to give the family time to seek help for Donnelly's mental illness while he was in jail, an effort to steer the situation toward treatment rather than punishment.

That plan unraveled quickly. While deputies were at the home for a second time, Morgan retrieved a revolver and went looking for Donnelly. Deputies were called back a third time, and Donnelly's body was found dead in a small outbuilding behind the home. Morgan fled the scene and was on the run for two days before he was arrested, the same account notes.

Prosecutor Describes a Family Betrayal

Solicitor Stumbo said Morgan hunted down and killed a family member because he had grown weary of dealing with the symptoms of Donnelly's mental illness. Stumbo added that Donnelly deserved compassion rather than bloodshed and death from a trusted family member, and said the solicitor's office will continue to support vulnerable victims and hold their abusers accountable.

A report republished by Yahoo states that Morgan admitted to shooting Donnelly multiple times. The same report says the 30-year sentence must be served without the possibility of parole under South Carolina law, leaving Morgan with no path to early release.

No Resolution for Unanswered Questions

The case closes a chapter that began with deputies trying to buy a struggling family time to get help, and ended instead with one of their own dead in an outbuilding. Morgan was convicted of killing his mentally ill adult stepson, and the eight-day trial produced the account prosecutors say shows a calculated pursuit rather than a split-second decision.