
A former Hambden Township fire official who is already facing felony charges in an alleged $1.6 million theft from his volunteer fire department is now under investigation for allegedly taking more than $100,000 from a small homeowners association he helped run for years. Geauga County prosecutors say a preliminary review points to missing funds at the Restful Lake Association, where Richard Vandevander served as treasurer and, later, as both president and treasurer.
Prosecutors Open a Second Financial Inquiry
Geauga County Prosecutor Jim Flaiz said his office is investigating whether Vandevander took more than $100,000 from Restful Lake Association, according to cleveland.com. Flaiz said a preliminary review points to more than $100,000 in misappropriated funds. Board members brought financial concerns to the prosecutor’s office, and investigators reportedly found a pattern of checks written to Vandevander from association accounts. Flaiz said the office plans to present its findings to a grand jury after the investigation is complete.
The association’s regulations require its treasurer to keep accurate records and document payments made under the board’s direction; trustees have the right to inspect the books, according to the same report. Restful Lake has about 150 residents in 95 homes. The association oversees annual dues, while residents are responsible for maintaining private roads and grounds, including paying for snowplowing.
What Association Records Show
Association records cited in the report show Vandevander was treasurer by March 2015, vice president and treasurer by August 2018, and president and treasurer by June 2024. The records place him in those leadership roles as the association’s financial information was presented to members and reviewed by board members.
At the May 21, 2023, annual meeting, Vandevander presented a summary of the prior year’s finances. Resident Lindsey McCoy questioned the board’s spending and proposed an audit, but withdrew the motion after no one seconded it, the outlet reported. Minutes from September 2025 list Vandevander as president and treasurer and say he reviewed the association’s finances, taxes and bills with board members. The association and Carol Szczepanik did not respond to cleveland.com’s requests for comment on the investigation, according to the report.
The $1.6 Million Fire Department Case
The HOA inquiry comes on top of a separate criminal case in which Vandevander, 59, is accused of stealing about $1.6 million from Hambden Volunteer Fire Department Inc. Prosecutors say that theft spanned from Jan. 9, 2023, through May 15, 2026, with funds allegedly taken through transfers and checks Vandevander wrote to himself, according to cleveland.com's earlier reporting. Prosecutors also allege that he forged signatures and omitted transactions from financial reports, and investigators believe the stolen fire department money was used to cover gambling losses, mostly at JACK Thistledown Racino in North Randall.
About $800,000 of the money allegedly stolen from the fire department came from a $2 million state grant that was meant to help build Hambden Township's new fire station, prosecutors said. Vandevander joined the fire department in 1987 and went on to serve as assistant chief and treasurer before resigning in July 2026. He was indicted in August 2026 on five felony charges — aggravated theft, telecommunications fraud, money laundering, falsification in a theft offense and forgery — and was arrested or turned himself in before his arraignment in Geauga County Common Pleas Court, where he pleaded not guilty on Aug. 17. His jury trial in that case, assigned to Judge Carolyn J. Paschke, is scheduled for March 2027.
Fire Department Works to Tighten Financial Controls
In the wake of the fire department case, Hambden's fire department has been working to add safeguards to its money-handling procedures and will continue evaluating additional measures. Fire Chief Scott Hildenbrand said the department now has both a treasurer and assistant treasurer, with multiple people able to monitor its bank accounts, according to the Geauga County Maple Leaf. All checks now require two authorized signatures, and transfers between accounts require approval from two authorized individuals, the outlet reported. Bills and monthly bank statements must also be reviewed and approved or signed by two people, and the department has hired a certified accounting firm to conduct annual audits and prepare taxes.
Hambden Township has also said it plans to establish a public audit committee that would include the fire department's participation, though that remains a stated plan rather than a completed step. Flaiz said his office intends to issue standard contract provisions for townships that contract with private fire companies, including a requirement for an independent audit once every three years during the life of the contract, according to the Maple Leaf's reporting.
Grant Funding and a Separate HOA Case
The Hambden Fire Department’s project page says it received $6.75 million from the USDA-RD Community Facilities Program in April 2024, followed later that year by a $2 million Ohio grant to fulfill the federal funding’s local-match requirement. That description explains the state grant’s matching role but does not detail other oversight requirements. As a separate comparison, the Miami Herald reported in April 2024 that prosecutors said a treasurer of the Lava Bluff HOA in Hurricane, Utah, took members’ fees from the association’s accounts between 2016 and March 2022. She later pleaded guilty to wire fraud and a false statement on a tax return. That case is from Utah and does not establish how any comparable Ohio cases were handled.
For now, the Restful Lake Association investigation remains in its preliminary stages, with prosecutors saying they will wait for the inquiry to conclude before taking any findings to a grand jury. No charges have been filed in connection with the association's finances, and whether the HOA has made any changes to its own financial oversight since the concerns surfaced has not been detailed.









