
A Hanover Borough landlord is facing criminal charges after he allegedly pepper-sprayed his tenant and her five-year-old son during an argument early Sunday morning. Jacob Nicholas Lagatare, 34, was taken into custody following the Nov. 15 incident on the 200 block of High Street and has since posted bail while the case moves toward a preliminary hearing.
Police were called to the address around 6:51 a.m. that morning, according to an affidavit of probable cause cited by the York Dispatch. Officers reported a strong odor of pepper spray inside the home when they arrived, the affidavit states. The tenant told police she had been in a verbal argument with Lagatare, her landlord, when he allegedly pepper-sprayed both her and her son.
Charging documents allege that Lagatare began spraying the woman while he was standing in front of the apartment's exit door, with her child positioned behind her. A video description included in the affidavit states that Lagatare had his back to the exit and was not being physically attacked or provoked when the spraying occurred. The same video reportedly shows the woman walking toward Lagatare and stopping roughly four to five feet in front of him before the confrontation escalated.
Child Heard Crying Out in Video Shown to Police
Lagatare showed officers video of the altercation himself, according to the report. In that footage, the five-year-old boy is heard saying, “ow, my eyes,” per the video description relayed in court documents. Lagatare allegedly admitted to police that he pepper-sprayed the woman but claimed he acted in self-defense.
He was charged with two misdemeanor counts of simple assault and two summary counts of harassment, court records show. Under Pennsylvania law, simple assault is generally graded as a second-degree misdemeanor, though the statute elevates the offense to a first-degree misdemeanor when committed against a child under 12 by someone 18 or older, according to Pennsylvania's Title 18, Section 2701. The available court records do not specify how that provision applies to each of the two counts filed against Lagatare.
Released on $12,000 Bail, Hearing Set for January
Lagatare was briefly detained at York County Prison before being released Sunday after posting $12,000 bail. A preliminary hearing in the case has been scheduled for Jan. 19, 2027. Attorney information for Lagatare was not available in court records at the time the case was reported, and he could not be reached for comment.
Pepper-spray allegations are not unheard of in York County. In 2019, a 31-year-old Red Lion man, Joel Edward Kirckhoff, was accused of spraying pepper spray at State Police troopers responding to a domestic disturbance, according to a criminal complaint affidavit reported by FOX43. That case led to charges including aggravated assault, drug possession, terroristic threats, simple assault, harassment, and disorderly conduct, the outlet reported.
No further updates on the outcome of the Hanover case or on the scheduled hearing have been made available.









