
Hay Jay Cafe, the Bennington coffee shop that carries the name of owner Deena Hannum's late daughter, is planning to open a second metro location on the ground floor of the Block 38 apartment complex at 38th Avenue and Dodge Street in Omaha's Blackstone neighborhood.
The move marks the next chapter for a business that began as a tribute to grief and has grown into a neighborhood fixture. According to KMTV 3 News Now, the cafe will keep its existing Bennington location while adding the Blackstone shop, giving Hay Jay two locations across the metro. The Block 38 site sits on the southwest corner of 38th Avenue and Dodge Street, a spot Grow Omaha describes as part of an apartment building under construction by Skylark Development in the Blackstone area.
The Blackstone cafe would join a substantial residential project: Block 38 is planned as a $22 million building with 131 apartments. Its Dodge Street location also places it along a major transit corridor. Metro’s ORBT service runs along Dodge between downtown and Westroads, with stops serving Midtown and other parts of the city. Block 38’s scale and location and ORBT’s route and service area put the cafe’s planned community space in a growing, transit-served part of Omaha.
Unlike the Bennington cafe, the new Blackstone space is expected to lean more heavily into coffee than food, per the station's report. Developer Josh Hannum, who is Deena Hannum's husband, said the layout will include a bar toward the back, an espresso machine and the usual cafe counter items up front, and a community area furnished with couches.
A Name Rooted in Loss
Hay Jay Cafe takes its name from Hazel Jane, Deena Hannum's daughter, who died at 18 months old. The station's earlier report notes that Hannum renamed the business to honor her daughter's memory, a decision that has shaped the cafe's identity ever since it opened in Bennington in the fall of 2024.
That connection will carry into the new Blackstone location. Deena Hannum said the family plans to include a feature at the new site honoring Hazel Jane and continuing her story, according to the same report. The timing carries its own weight for the family, since Hazel Jane's angel-versary falls in February. “No matter what, 'Hay Jay' will be going around,” Hannum said.
Conflicting Timelines for the Opening
Exactly when the Blackstone cafe will open remains unsettled. The family hopes to open in February, the station reported, tying the timing to Hazel Jane's angel-versary. Grow Omaha, however, has reported that opening is planned for spring 2027, according to its news brief on the project. Neither timeline has been independently confirmed, and the discrepancy between the two reports has not been resolved.
Hannum also said the family had been trying to return to the midtown area, a goal that predates the Block 38 announcement. That ambition traces back to Hay Jay's roots: the business first started in 2017 as a drive-thru shop on North Saddle Creek Road, per Grow Omaha's account of the company's history.
The business has changed form and name as it moved between neighborhoods. Josh Hannum opened a Midtown drive-through called Midtown Reality Coffee in 2017; it later became MRC, then Hay Jay Coffee in 2021. The family initially envisioned a drive-through in Bennington, but the plan developed into a full-service scratch kitchen. Hay Jay Cafe opened there on Oct. 17, 2024. The family’s account of that evolution traces a path from a small Midtown coffee stand to the cafe now preparing to return to the urban core.
A Winding Road Through Omaha's Coffee Scene
The North Saddle Creek shop's story did not end smoothly. Hay Jay Coffee closed there on August 18, 2024, with Hannum describing it at the time as a temporary closure with no set timeline to reopen, the station reported in earlier coverage. That closure came as the area around North Saddle Creek was undergoing a streetscape project intended to make the neighborhood more walkable and friendlier to cyclists and pedestrians, according to the same report.
The Saddle Creek streetscape project also connects Josh Hannum to the business district Hay Jay once called home: he was chair of the Saddle Creek Business Improvement District when the project broke ground in May 2025. The roughly $5 million effort was designed to improve the corridor with wider sidewalks, a pedestrian-and-bike path, landscaping, lighting and parking. The project’s planned improvements were intended to make the area safer and more walkable, adding another layer to the neighborhood’s ongoing redevelopment as the Hannums plan a new Midtown-area business.
From that uncertain pause, Hay Jay reemerged in Bennington later that year under its new name, and now stands ready to expand into Blackstone, carrying its origin story into a new corner of the city's coffee scene.









