
A Hempstead man accused of raiding gym lockers for credit cards and personal information across Nassau County was arrested Monday night, police said, capping a string of alleged thefts that stretched from mid-September into early November. Russell Portnoy, 34, now faces dozens of criminal counts tied to the scheme.
Police said Portnoy opened victims’ gym lockers to steal their credit cards and other identifying information, then used the stolen cards to make purchases, according to Daily Voice. He was arrested Monday night, Nov. 16, cops said, after what investigators describe as a monthslong pattern of targeting fitness businesses in the area.
A Pattern That Started at One Garden City LA Fitness
Investigators say Portnoy’s alleged spree began at an LA Fitness on Steward Avenue in Garden City, which he targeted six times between Sept. 17 and Oct. 3, per the same account. He then allegedly moved on to a different LA Fitness location, this one on Marcus Avenue in New Hyde Park, on Oct. 15.
The alleged thefts didn’t stop there. Police say Portnoy struck Metro Physical & Aquatic Therapy in Garden City on Oct. 30, then hit a Planet Fitness in Carle Place on Nov. 5 — the final incident listed before his arrest less than two weeks ago.
A Long List of Charges Ahead of Arraignment
According to Daily Voice, Portnoy faces nine counts of fourth-degree grand larceny, two counts of first-degree scheme to defraud, and nine counts of fourth-degree possession of stolen property. He also faces 11 counts of second-degree identity theft, six counts of third-degree identity theft, and eight counts of third-degree illegal possession of personal ID, the outlet reported.
LongIsland.com reported an additional count of third-degree grand larceny along with 10 counts of petit larceny, on top of the other charges. The outlet said Portnoy was scheduled to be arraigned Tuesday at First District Court on Main Street in Hempstead.
Under New York law, second-degree identity theft generally involves using another person’s identifying information to obtain goods, money, property or services, or using credit in that person’s name in an amount exceeding $500, or causing that person financial loss, according to an excerpt of the statute published by the New York State Senate.
Part of a Broader Wave of Locker Thefts
Portnoy’s case lands amid what police describe as a frequent problem at Long Island gyms. Officers told CBS New York that locker-room thefts are a crime they have been seeing a lot of lately.
Nassau County has seen similar cases before. Police previously said a suspected thief believed responsible for ransacking an Equinox in Woodbury and an LA Fitness in Levittown made off with cash, credit cards, jewelry, airline tickets, iPhones and drivers’ licenses, per a separate CBS New York report. Nassau County Police Inspector Kenneth Lack described that suspect’s method to the station, saying, “When there’s a lot of people gathered outside he follows them in. The person at the desk is distracted. He is able to make his way to the locker room.”
Elsewhere on Long Island, Patch reported that Devon Barrett, 33, of Central Islip, was accused of entering nine victims’ gym lockers between Feb. 14 and Feb. 25, taking car keys and then additional items from their vehicles, and using or attempting to use stolen credit cards at nearby locations on seven occasions. In Brooklyn, police were searching for a man accused of breaking into lockers 12 times at the same Planet Fitness in Bushwick, stealing wallets, jackets and $2,270 in cash, according to ABC7 New York.









