North Jersey/ Food & Drinks

Highland Park's Birnn Chocolates, a 111-Year-Old NJ Candy Maker, Closes Within Days

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 14, 2026
Highland Park's Birnn Chocolates, a 111-Year-Old NJ Candy Maker, Closes Within DaysCleveland Ave. — Reported Site of Closing Chocolate Store
Google Street View

Birnn Chocolates, the Highland Park chocolate maker whose roots stretch back more than a century, says its Cleveland Avenue store will be closing for good within a few days of its announcement this week. The news lands just as the company's busiest season of the year gets underway, leaving longtime customers scrambling to say goodbye to a New Jersey candy institution.

The closure was confirmed in a report from nj.com, which cited the company's own announcement that the Highland Park location will “be closing for good in a few days.” According to the outlet's account, the store's owners also urged customers in a post to a private Highland Park social media group to purchase holiday candy while supplies last, with no further detail offered about the reason behind the sudden shutdown.

Birnn's story goes back to 1915, when Charles Henry Birnn opened Birnn & Knopf Candy makers in Brooklyn, New York, the same report notes. The family's New Jersey chapter began in 1932, when Birnn started Regina Sweets in Highland Park, a venture that was renamed two years later after he moved operations to Bayard Street in New Brunswick, per the same account.

From Regina Sweets to a Phoenix-Like Rebirth

By the 1950s, the company had grown to 11 stores across New Jersey and Pennsylvania, though a 1965 fire destroyed the flagship New Brunswick store. The Birnn family sold the company in 1974, and Birnn Candy ceased operations altogether in 1981 — the same year the business was resurrected as Birnn Chocolates, according to the company's own About Us history.

Manufacturing had already moved to Cleveland Avenue in Highland Park back in 1954, and the company says operations have remained at that address ever since. John Cunnell took over as head of Birnn Chocolates in 1991 and continued manufacturing a full line of traditional chocolates in New Jersey, a run that stretched on for decades at the same Highland Park site described on the company's website.

A Factory and Storefront Under One Roof

Birnn says its retail store sits in the same building as the factory where all of its chocolates are made, a detail that underscores just how intertwined the shop and its manufacturing have been. The company also touts a string of more recent milestones: its chocolates became Fair Trade and GMO-free in 2019, e-commerce capabilities were added in 2020, and the store itself was completely renovated in 2021.

A 2023 visit to the Cleveland Avenue store by nj.com offered a glimpse of just how much work went into keeping that legacy running. Cunnell told the outlet that the company's milk chocolate cashew turtle had been made the same way since 1932, and he described Christmas as the busiest time of year for the small, high-end chocolate producer.

Thousands of Pounds of Chocolate, Shipped Worldwide

During the 2023 Easter season, the factory expected to turn out about 2,000 pounds of chocolate confections per week, according to that same nj.com report, with roughly 200 different Easter items on offer at prices ranging from $1.60 to $35. Cunnell also said at the time that about 20% of the chocolates sold at the store were shipped all over the world, a sign of how far the Highland Park brand's reputation had traveled beyond Middlesex County.

No information has been made available about what led to this week's closure announcement, nor about whether manufacturing at the Cleveland Avenue factory will continue in any form once the storefront shuts its doors. For now, Birnn Chocolates' message to its community has been simple and urgent: come get your holiday candy while it's still on the shelves, because after 111 years, the clock on this Highland Park institution is running out.