
The Four Saints Club at 281 E. Whittier St. in Columbus is set to reopen Dec. 1, nearly three years after it shut its doors in December 2023. The club will welcome the general public through Jan. 31, 2027, before shifting to members-only access on Feb. 1, 2027, with entry-level memberships starting at $35 a month.
According to the Lexington Herald-Leader, the club was purchased in 2023 by Michael Kelley, John Duffy and Bobby Whitman, who have transformed the once-fraying social hall into what the paper describes as an upscale dining and cocktail destination. The report notes the Covid-19 pandemic and dwindling membership had threatened the club's future before the sale. Kelley told the outlet the goal was distinctive décor, service and memorable events while preserving tradition, adding that the club brings forward its spirit with new bones.
Bobby Whitman, meanwhile, said the old club felt special despite being outdated and rundown, and he acknowledged the renovated version will initially seem completely different to frequent former members. The renovation included accessible restrooms, an expanded kitchen and rooftop solar panels, though the club held onto its three-sided bar, a holdover from its earlier life as a neighborhood gathering spot.
A Building With Roots in 1890s Theater Row
The structure at 281 E. Whittier Street has a layered past. ColumbusMakesArt.com says the 4-S Auditorium Building was built in 1890 and was originally owned by Frank Herboltzeimer, operating as a movie theatre. The same account notes the building was sold to the Steelton Theatre Group in 1932 and continued screening films before the Auditorium Building Company purchased it in 1962, giving rise to the name still used today, the 4-S Club or 4 Saints Club.
That timeline runs alongside a separate construction history reported by the Herald-Leader, which states the building was constructed as the Schiller Theater in 1912 and renamed the Columbia Theater in 1918. Per that account, the Columbia Theater held 400 seats and screened films until 1952. The two sourced histories differ on the structure's origin year and ownership details, and the dossier does not reconcile them.
Four Catholic Societies Behind the Club's Name
The Lexington Herald-Leader reports that the four Catholic fraternal organizations joined forces to purchase Auditorium Hall on South High Street in 1914, and the club was formally established in 1940 before moving to East Whittier Street in 1962.
Over the decades, the club hosted Lenten fish fries, euchre tournaments, weddings and St. Patrick's Day celebrations, the newspaper notes. The owners have identified approximately 450 names connected to the founding organizations and plan to offer complimentary first-year memberships to eligible members of those four founding societies.
New Kitchen, New Cocktail Menu, Old Bones
When it reopens, Ryan Reidel, who has more than two decades of restaurant experience, will serve as general manager, while Erik Till takes on the role of executive chef. Seth Laufman developed the cocktail program, which the Herald-Leader says includes drink-menu sections titled Act One, Act Two, Intermission, Act Three and Encore.
The club's website describes its approach to food as a small kitchen with a careful menu, offering more than just snacks and small plates, with each dish using quality ingredients well prepared, according to foursaintsclub.com. Its drink list emphasizes classic builds, Manhattans, Martinis and Old Fashioneds, built precisely, with no apologies for orthodoxy, per the same source.
Commissioned Portraits Honor the Club's Namesakes
Artist Grace Morbitzer Collins created four portraits depicting St. John the Baptist, St. Francis Xavier, St. Joseph and St. Paul for the reopened space, with each portrait taking approximately one month to complete, the Herald-Leader reports. Collins said participating in the project was an honor, and she said she hopes the club connects community with its past and ancestors.
The club's website lists an Individual membership with one access card and one login, according to foursaintsclub.com. Members may enter any evening the club is open, with unlimited guests when the member is present, the site states.









