Phoenix/ Politics & Govt

Judge Refuses to Halt South32 Mine Near Tucson, Clears Path for Construction

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 10, 2026
Judge Refuses to Halt South32 Mine Near Tucson, Clears Path for ConstructionEvo A. DeConcini United States Courthouse — Site of Federal Court Ruling
Google Street View

Construction will keep moving forward at South32's Hermosa project in the Patagonia Mountains southeast of Tucson after a federal judge refused to block the work while a lawsuit over endangered species protections plays out. U.S. District Judge Raner Collins denied a request from two environmental groups for a preliminary injunction that would have paused the mine's buildout, but he made clear his ruling settles far less than it might seem.

The denial, reported by Tucson Sentinel, came after the Center for Biological Diversity and Patagonia Area Resource Alliance sued the U.S. Forest Service and the Fish and Wildlife Service, arguing the agencies failed to meet their congressionally-mandated duties to protect species as required by the Endangered Species Act. Collins was careful to note the limits of his order, stating it does not adjudicate all claims, validate every aspect of the project, or authorize departures from existing permit conditions, according to the outlet's report.

That distinction matters because the underlying case is still very much alive. Per the Tucson Sentinel, Collins gave both sides two weeks to submit a briefing schedule as the lawsuit moves forward, meaning the legal fight over whether federal agencies adequately protected wildlife in the Patagonia Mountains is only beginning.

What's at Stake in the Patagonia Mountains

The Hermosa project sits in the Patagonia Mountains about 50 miles southeast of Tucson, per the same outlet's reporting, and is expected to produce five federally designated critical minerals, including zinc, silver, and manganese. The project is positioned as a prospective domestic source of manganese while increasing domestic production of zinc.

Manganese is also used in batteries.

South32 has leaned on that framing in defending the project, telling reporters that the mine will use 90 percent less water than other mines, according to the Tucson Sentinel. The company also says it has committed to more than 135 conservation, mitigation, and monitoring measures developed in coordination with federal agencies, Tribes, and local stakeholders, according to KOLD News 13.

A Large Footprint, Not All of It Mined

The scale of the federal approval underlying the project is considerable. KOLD's report notes the federal approval covers mining-related activities across more than 52,000 acres of public land, though that does not mean all of the land would be physically mined — a distinction the station emphasized in its coverage of the ruling. The station also reported that the judge heard arguments on November 3.

This isn't the first time opponents of mining activity in the Patagonia Mountains have sought court intervention. In a separate 2023 dispute involving different projects, the Sunnyside and Flux Canyon exploratory sites in the Coronado National Forest, the Ninth Circuit denied a bid to block exploratory work while an appeal proceeded, according to the Tucson Sentinel's earlier reporting. That case was distinct from the Hermosa project now at the center of the current lawsuit.

Imports and the National-Security Argument

A South Carolina mining location produces ultra-low-grade manganese, while company estimates put the share of battery-grade manganese processed in China at more than 95 percent.

For now, those bigger-picture supply arguments remain secondary to the narrower legal question still before Collins: whether the Forest Service and Fish and Wildlife Service lived up to their obligations under the Endangered Species Act. With briefing yet to be scheduled, that question — and the fate of the broader lawsuit — remains unresolved even as South32 may continue work in the Patagonia Mountains.