Oklahoma City/ Politics & Govt

Judge Sanctions State Farm, Orders Executives to Norman Trial

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 17, 2026
Judge Sanctions State Farm, Orders Executives to Norman TrialSource: JadeP2020 / Wikimedia Commons

A Cleveland County judge has sanctioned State Farm and ordered company executives to testify live before a Norman jury, after a hail-damaged roof turned into a fight over documents.

Don and Brenda Foster sued in 2023, after a low offer on a house the storm had left leaking. Their lawyers want a January trial to reach past one inspection, into internal replacement targets and a consulting firm they say helped shape how claims get handled. Judge Thad Balkman issued the sanctions to push State Farm to comply with court orders, KFOR reported Monday. The company has to produce documents before the case goes to trial, and executives who have already testified in depositions will have to do it again, live, in Norman.

What the Order Requires

Balkman's order sets a sequence, not a verdict. State Farm has to produce documents before the Foster case heads to trial in January 2027. Executives who have already given depositions must then testify live before the jury in Norman. Accenture, the consulting company drawn into the lawsuit, must send a live witness to Oklahoma for a deposition before trial.

Nick Marr, an attorney for the Fosters, said Balkman had exhausted his options after months of patience. Jeff Marr, founder of Marr Law Firm and also representing the couple, accused State Farm of withholding documents and evidence and of not complying with court orders. He said documents and testimony withheld under privilege will become public record after the order. He recalled that he had not seen this kind of order in a State Farm case since the 2006 Watkins class action.

The company answered by limiting what any of that decides. It said the ruling concerns document requests and witness testimony. "It does not determine whether State Farm improperly handled the customer's claim." State Farm said it takes its legal-process obligations seriously, has provided extensive information during the litigation, will address the matters through the legal process, and remains focused on Oklahoma customers. A judge sanctioned it, in the same dispute, for not complying with court orders.

The Roof State Farm Called Fine

The Fosters' lawsuit starts with a house, not a slide deck. They filed in 2023 after hail damage left leaks in their home and State Farm made a low offer, according to KFOR. Chad Ihrig represents them, along with Jeff and Nick Marr.

State Farm's account of the loss was that the shingles were fine, even with damaged soft metals and leaks in the house, as reported by KFOR. The company denies the claims against it. It says it stands behind its claims practices and evaluates each claim based on the loss facts and the customer's policy. The sanctions go to compliance and witnesses. They do not decide whether that offer should have bought a new roof.

Jeff Marr said the Fosters allege State Farm operated a scheme, or a scam, and made hundreds of millions of dollars from it, per a report from KFOR. That is their allegation, carried into court by their lawyer. It is not what Balkman adopted in the order KFOR reported Monday, and no jury has heard it yet. The January setting is the first time those executives would have to answer it live in Norman, rather than in a deposition.

Who Put 5 to 10 Percent on a Slide

A PowerPoint shown to State Farm executives described 5% to 10% as the industry-best rate for full roof replacements due to wind or hail damage, as noted by KFOR. The number is in the case. Credit for it is already contested. State Farm testified that it did not validate the figures. Nick Marr said Accenture's attorneys said they did not develop them.

Marr's description of the firm does not stop at the slide. He said Accenture served as State Farm's right hand through the inception and rollout of the Fire Model Enhancement program, and that Accenture employees were given State Farm laptops and email addresses. Balkman ordered Accenture to send a live witness to Oklahoma for a deposition before trial. The Fosters' lawyers want that witness on the program's origins. The order itself requires the appearance.

Documents released in related roof-claim litigation point to a separate starting line, NonDoc reported in September. In 2020, State Farm began acting on a hypothesis that it was replacing roofs too often and launched a wind-and-hail claims initiative in Dallas County, Texas. Plaintiffs' attorneys in that litigation said the initiative affected hundreds of millions of dollars in denied claims in Oklahoma and billions of dollars in claims nationwide. That is an attorneys' account from related cases. It is not a figure adopted in the Foster sanctions order, and it is not the same allegation Jeff Marr attached to a scheme.

Same Carrier, Different Courtrooms

The Foster order is not the only time a judge has pushed State Farm for files. On the recent roof docket, it is the one that came with sanctions.

In the separate Hursh lawsuit, also filed in 2023, State Farm offered the family $1,400 against an estimated $22,000 in storm damage, NonDoc reported. Attorneys said an Oklahoma County judge ordered the company to produce key documents and make several executives available for depositions, News 9 reported. That judge did not impose sanctions at the hearing. The $1,400 offer belongs to the Hursh file, not to Don and Brenda Foster.

In West v. State Farm, Judge Grant Sheperd ordered the release of 31 company documents, NonDoc reported. Different plaintiffs, a different proceeding, another order aimed at paper rather than a verdict.

The case Jeff Marr reached back for is further from a hail claim. On May 26, 2006, a jury in a separate Oklahoma class action found that State Farm had recklessly and maliciously mishandled claims from families whose homes were damaged by tornadoes in 1999, CNN reported. The jury awarded lead plaintiffs Donald and Bridget Watkins almost $13 million in total damages. Marr was talking about the kind of order he had seen since then, not asking a Cleveland County jury to retry 1999.

Premiums, Then a January Calendar

These lawsuits are moving through a state where the insurance bill is already a household problem. A 2026 LendingTree report, as described by The Oklahoman, found home insurance costs averaged 9.3% of household income, the highest share in the nation. The same report found premiums in Oklahoma had risen 54.5% since 2020. The Oklahoman published those figures in January, months before Balkman's sanctions order. They measure what coverage costs households. They do not assign fault in the Foster file.

Between now and the Norman trial, the enforceable pieces are the ones the judge already named. Documents before January 2027. An Accenture witness in Oklahoma for a pretrial deposition. State Farm executives, already deposed, in front of jurors. The company says it will meet its obligations through the legal process, and that the process still has not decided the Fosters' claim. The order reported Monday says the next part of that process happens in person, in Norman, with the documents produced first.