Boston/ Crime & Emergencies

Judge Weighs Worcester Couple's Convictions After Gift to Victim

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 17, 2026
Judge Weighs Worcester Couple's Convictions After Gift to VictimU.S. District Court — Weighs Sotos’ Conviction Motions
Google Street View

Kiersten and Moises Soto's 18-year sentences are already off the books. What a Boston federal judge has not decided is whether their sex-trafficking convictions should come off with them.

U.S. District Judge Myong J. Joun vacated the Worcester couple's sentences in July and is now testing defense claims that the trial judge's conduct, including a personal gift to the victim, tainted the case. As MassLive reported, he gave both sides two weeks to file more evidence or legal briefs before he rules. The couple remains in the custody of the U.S. Marshals while that question sits open.

A Card, a Bracelet and an Empty Chair

Before a January sentencing hearing, U.S. District Judge Margaret R. Guzman prepared a gift for the victim: a handwritten card about her courage, a silver bracelet and several seashells. On January 23, during a break, a clerk handed a prosecutor an envelope meant for the young woman. She was not in court. The defense was out of the room.

Prosecutors said they did not open the envelope until sentencing had ended. By then Guzman, who had presided over the trial, had imposed 18 years in prison on each defendant, followed by five years of probation, and ordered $138,000 in restitution.

The timing is the defense's point. Between February and May, the Sotos asked the court to overturn the convictions or order a new sentencing hearing, The Boston Globe reported. Guzman recused herself on February 20, after the defense moved for a new trial, and the case was reassigned to Joun. Lawyers for the couple argue the communication created the appearance that she favored a key prosecution witness.

On that piece, the two sides meet. Both agree Guzman's conduct at the sentencing hearing at least created an appearance of impropriety. Prosecutors still oppose a new trial. They say a different judge should handle resentencing.

Rulings the Defense Says Shaped the Verdict

The gift came months after the verdict. The defense wants Joun to treat it as the explanation for what happened in the courtroom, not as a separate lapse at sentencing.

Defense lawyers argue Guzman showed bias during trial by limiting cross-examination and repeatedly dismissing and deriding them. Michael L. Tumposky said that bias was obvious at the time, though the defense did not then understand why.

John S. Day tied the rulings to the issue he says decided the case: the victim's credibility. He said Guzman's limits kept jurors from fully evaluating it. The evidence the defense sought to introduce included a pending Worcester drug case involving the dealer from whom the Sotos bought drugs. Day said proper vetting could likely have led the jury to a different verdict.

Joun is considering whether the trial would have ended in acquittal under a different judge. He has also questioned how discretionary evidentiary rulings, including ones that might have been legally incorrect, should affect that review. A wrong call on what jurors may hear is not, by itself, the question he framed. The question is whether those calls change the outcome he has to reconstruct.

What Prosecutors Say the Record Already Shows

The government describes a case that ran from February through May 2022. Prosecutors say Kiersten and Moises Soto used violence and threats to force the victim into commercial sex across New England to fund drug use. They say the coercion ran through her addiction, including withholding Percocet and fentanyl, and that the couple recorded her during withdrawal while berating and threatening her.

Kiersten Soto, they say, organized prostitution dates online and arranged transportation to and from them. They say Moises Soto used extreme violence when the couple believed the victim was not earning enough, was hiding drugs or had missed a date. Those are prosecution allegations about the underlying crimes, recounted as the government defends the verdict, not a fresh set of findings on the bias motions.

Assistant U.S. Attorney Stephen Hassink argued the case was never a one-witness trial. The government called six other witnesses in its case-in-chief, including a police officer who noted the victim's injuries and a driver who transported her to and from dates. Hassink said the defendants' own accounts, together with that other evidence, would have supported conviction even if the defense had put its intended evidence before the jury.

He also drew a line at the calendar. Guzman's conduct, he argued, came four months after trial and cannot establish bias while the trial was underway. Resentencing, he said, is the appropriate remedy.

A Vacated Sentence and a 15-Year Floor

The practical split is already in the record. The sentences Guzman imposed do not currently stand. Joun wiped them out in July. The convictions are the live dispute.

If those convictions remain and no new trial is ordered, each defendant faces a minimum 15-year prison sentence. That floor sits below the 18-year terms Guzman chose, but it is still the consequence the government is trying to preserve. Any new sentence, prosecutors have agreed, should come from a judge other than Guzman.

Joun has not said which argument he will accept. He has left both sides a short window to add evidence or briefs before he decides whether the verdicts survive the judge who heard them.