
Kalshi is warning that New York Attorney General Letitia James’ lawsuit against the prediction-market exchange could force it to shut down nationwide, not just within the state. The company made the warning after a federal judge sent the case back to state court on Thursday, rejecting Kalshi’s bid to keep the fight in federal hands.
Federal Judge Boots Case Back to Manhattan
U.S. District Judge Vernon Broderick ruled that the alleged violation of the federal Wire Act did not raise a federal question substantial enough to establish jurisdiction, according to Law360. New York’s suit accuses Kalshi of running an unlicensed sports betting operation, the outlet reported. Broderick did not decide whether Kalshi’s contracts actually violate New York gambling law — he ruled only that the dispute belongs in state court, where it now returns to Manhattan Supreme Court.
Kalshi has since asked a New York state judge not to grant the Attorney General’s office an emergency order against it without first hearing from the company, according to Crypto Times. The company argued that an order reaching its contracts would shut down a federally regulated exchange for every customer, everywhere, the outlet reported. As of Friday, the court had not scheduled a hearing, and the Attorney General’s office had not filed a renewed temporary restraining order application, per the same account.
A $22 Billion Business on the Line
Kalshi cited its scale in making the case that a sweeping order could force liquidation of open positions, pointing to $178 billion in annualized trading volume and a $22 billion valuation, the report notes. Those figures track with a funding round reported earlier this year: The New York Times reported that Kalshi raised $1 billion in a round led by Coatue Management valuing the start-up at $22 billion, with annualized trading volume that had more than tripled over the prior six months. The Times also reported the company’s annualized revenue, an extrapolation of current figures, at more than $1.5 billion.
Kalshi’s letter said the exchange launched in July 2021 and has been headquartered in New York ever since, according to the Crypto Times account. Court records on CourtListener show the legal fight stretching back months: KalshiEX LLC removed the case from state court to federal court on July 31, 2026, New York moved to send it back on August 7, and Kalshi filed a memorandum opposing that remand on August 21.
Broader Legal Battles Across the Country
New York is not the only state pressing the issue. A divided Fourth Circuit panel recently held that Kalshi’s sports prediction markets are likely subject to Maryland’s gambling laws, according to Bloomberg Law, which also reported that the appellate panel affirmed a 2025 federal district court decision denying Kalshi’s preliminary injunction request against Maryland gaming regulators.
The scale of the fight reflects how fast prediction markets have grown. Combined monthly global trading volume on prediction markets was about $50.6 billion in July 2026, according to CBS Sports, which separately noted that legal U.S. sportsbooks took in about $14 billion per month in wagers in 2025.
What Happens Next
With the case back in Manhattan Supreme Court, New York may renew its temporary restraining order application, and Kalshi has asked for the chance to challenge any such request before it takes effect rather than face another order issued without its input, as the Crypto Times report describes. For now, no hearing date has been set, leaving the exchange’s next moves — and the broader question of how New York’s gambling laws apply to its contracts — unresolved.









