
The Kansas Supreme Court has unanimously upheld the conviction and life sentence of Carlos Alejandro Anderson-Honeycutt, the man found guilty of killing his ex-girlfriend, 24-year-old Brittnee Wicker, in southeast Wichita in 2023. The justices denied his request for a new trial, rejecting his argument that prosecutors withheld evidence that could have changed the outcome at trial.
Doorbell Video at the Center of the Appeal
According to KWCH, Anderson-Honeycutt's appeal centered on footage from a doorbell camera belonging to Wicker's neighbor. An investigating officer had recorded what he saw while scrolling through thumbnail snippets of the videos, and the state inadvertently failed to turn over the officer's phone recording to the defense before trial. Anderson-Honeycutt argued this failure amounted to the state withholding favorable evidence and should entitle him to a new trial.
The state's high court disagreed. The Kansas Supreme Court ruled that the state's failure to turn over the officer's phone recording was not grounds for a new trial because the recording was not favorable to Anderson-Honeycutt in the first place. In deciding unanimously to affirm the denial, the court also rejected his broader contention that the state had withheld favorable evidence, and upheld his conviction outright.
The appeal turned on the constitutional rule from Brady v. Maryland: prosecutors must disclose evidence favorable to the defense when it is material to guilt or punishment. In this case, the Kansas Supreme Court found the late-disclosed phone video did not meet that first requirement. It showed doorbell-camera thumbnails and recording details, but the number of clips was already established by other evidence and was not a disputed fact at trial, the court said. The justices also rejected the argument that speculation about what further investigation the video might have prompted was enough to require a new trial.
A Domestic Violence Case Investigators Said Ended in Murder
Wicker was found dead inside her home near Pawnee and Oliver from an apparent gunshot wound. Investigators determined her death was a domestic violence case, and they pursued leads that led to Anderson-Honeycutt's arrest a couple of days after the shooting. He was ultimately apprehended near the U.S.-Mexico border, with help from the Department of Homeland Security and U.S. Customs and Border Patrol, according to the same report from KWCH.
Conviction and Sentencing
The case was decided after a bench trial, not a jury trial. Anderson-Honeycutt admitted shooting Wicker but argued the killing was not premeditated; the state contended he planned it and tried to make a gang member appear responsible. The Kansas Supreme Court opinion recounts that the neighbor’s doorbell camera recorded 292 clips on the day of the killing, while the detective’s phone recording showed thumbnails and details such as each clip’s time and recording trigger.
Anderson-Honeycutt was convicted of killing his ex-girlfriend in 2023 and was sentenced in 2025 to life in prison without the possibility of parole. With the Kansas Supreme Court's ruling now affirming both the denial of his new trial motion and the underlying conviction, that sentence stands.
The sentence is commonly called a Hard 50: a life sentence with a 50-year mandatory minimum before parole eligibility, rather than a sentence that categorically bars parole. Kansas law allows a judge to impose that minimum for premeditated first-degree murder. Anderson-Honeycutt’s conviction and sentence therefore remain in place after the state Supreme Court rejected his bid for a new trial.









