
For three decades, Sutter County firefighters have answered the call in Live Oak, covering roughly 9,500 residents out of a single station on Fir Street. Now that arrangement is on the clock. The city's current fire-services contract is set to expire Nov. 30, and with days to go, Live Oak and Sutter County have not reached a new agreement.
The Live Oak City Council was scheduled to take up the issue at a meeting Wednesday at 6 p.m. at council chambers, 9955 Live Oak Blvd., according to FOX40. The outlet, citing reporter Rowena Shaddox, reported that the city has been working with the county on funding options since July, but a fix has not materialized. City Manager Ben Moody has said Live Oak simply lacks the funding to keep the current fire service running as is.
The stakes of letting that contract lapse are not abstract. Sutter County Fire Station 5 in Live Oak handles about 1,500 calls a year — roughly five 911 calls a day — with two firefighters on duty around the clock, every day of the year, according to Capt. Brandon McReynolds. Without a resolution, FOX40's reporting indicates the station could close by Dec. 1.
What Options Are on the Table
City leaders have floated several paths forward, per the FOX40 report. Live Oak could simply extend its existing fire-services contract, start its own municipal fire department, lean on neighboring agencies for mutual aid, or build a hybrid model that pairs Bi-County Ambulance with in-house personnel, interns, volunteers or per-diem staff.
One option drawing particular attention is a proposal to rely on Bi-County Ambulance for medical calls, which make up the bulk of the station's workload. Under that plan, a single EMT in a pickup truck — rather than a fire engine staffed with two firefighters — would respond to medical emergencies. Moody has said Bi-County currently responds to about 90% of health calls but acknowledged it would represent a reduced level of service.
Capt. McReynolds has pushed back on that framing, saying an EMT working alone out of a pickup truck cannot match the service level or response resources that trained firefighters bring to a scene, per FOX40's reporting.
The Response-Time Gap
Moody has also laid out what he sees as the starkest consequence of losing the current setup: speed. Sutter County Fire crews are typically on scene within two to three minutes, he said, according to Yahoo News. If Live Oak instead has to rely on a service model built around outside agencies, Moody said, residents could be looking at response times closer to 15 to 20 minutes.
Moody has floated the possibility that a different provider could end up occupying the existing fire station, or that service could instead be run out of another location altogether, the outlet's report notes. None of those scenarios has been finalized, and the station's ultimate fate was not resolved as of this reporting.
A Budget Shortfall Years in the Making
The fire-contract crunch is tied to a broader financial squeeze. Live Oak is facing a general-fund shortfall of nearly $1.9 million, according to the Appeal-Democrat. City officials have offered slightly different figures for the scale of the gap: Moody told FOX40 the city brings in 10 million dollars and spends 15, while the Appeal-Democrat separately reported annual revenues of $10.5 million against total outflow of $15.3 million.
The squeeze has been building for months. In a proposed 2026–27 budget outlined by The Gridley Herald, Live Oak planned to slash fire-service contract funding from $1.3 million down to $750,000. That same budget crunch has already hit the sheriff's side of public safety — Live Oak's deputy patrol staffing was cut in half after a sales tax measure meant to shore up Sutter County sheriff's patrol and fire services failed at the ballot. FOX40's reporting refers to that measure as Measure F, while Yahoo News identifies a separate one-cent sales tax measure as Measure G, reporting it was projected to raise about $22.5 million before trailing by more than 500 votes in preliminary results and appearing headed for defeat.
Not the First Time Around This Table
This isn't the first time Live Oak and Sutter County have had to renegotiate fire coverage under financial pressure. The two sides' prior contract expired on June 30, 2022, and the Appeal-Democrat reported that Live Oak went without a formal fire-services agreement for more than a year afterward before the council unanimously approved a new five-year contract.
That 2023 agreement, detailed in a Live Oak City Council report, shifted the cost split so the city covered 85% of operational costs while the county covered 15%, up from an 80-20 split — a change that added $40,000 to the city's costs. The same agreement made Live Oak responsible for the full cost of a battalion chief position, priced at $256,239 per year, and was set to run through Dec. 31, 2029, with either side able to walk away by giving 12 months' written notice.
That contract also called for round-the-clock staffing of 2.0 personnel, with a minimum rank of Engineer, at the existing Live Oak station. The current standoff plays out against that same backdrop of thin staffing margins countywide — the Sacramento Bee has reported that Sutter County Fire has been contending with four fire-engineer vacancies and five additional firefighters on leave, prompting rotating temporary closures at two of the department's three stations, though the Live Oak station was reported to remain open throughout those rotations.









