Greater Tulsa/ Tulsa/ Crime & Emergencies

Loose Cows Keep Crashing Into Cars on McIntosh County Highway, Jurisdiction Gets Messy

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 18, 2026
Loose Cows Keep Crashing Into Cars on McIntosh County Highway, Jurisdiction Gets MessyOklahoma Highway Patrol Car
Alexander Schimmeck / Unsplash

William Summers was driving along Highway 9 near Raiford on a dark September night when a black cow standing in the road seemed to appear out of nowhere. He hit it. The impact temporarily left him unable to see, totaled his Ford F-150, and killed the animal.

Summers told FOX23 that the cow’s dark coloring blended into the road in his headlights, and he could not see it until it was too late. He said he later saw Facebook posts warning that cows were loose along the highway, including one post that read simply, “cows are back out, again,” and another describing a driver hitting a cow near Raiford.

A Stretch of Highway With a Pattern

Summers’ wreck is not an isolated case. A review of Oklahoma Highway Patrol data found eight reported crashes involving cows along an eight-mile stretch of Highway 9 since the beginning of 2025, according to the station’s report. Three people were injured in those crashes, and OHP said weather was not a factor in any of them.

Another driver told the outlet he, too, had hit a cow on the same highway. The McIntosh County Sheriff’s Office posted in September that it had responded to multiple complaints about cattle loose near Highway 9 west of Raiford.

Why One Case Stalled at the County Line

What happened after Summers’ crash is where things got complicated. According to a Facebook post from the sheriff’s office, the matter had been turned over to the Muscogee Nation after the agency determined the identified cattle owner was a tribal citizen and that state law could not be applied against him. The Muscogee Nation did not respond to the station’s request for comment.

The sheriff said there is confusion surrounding the man’s tribal citizenship, and that a person identified as a tribal citizen has a pending case in McIntosh County court. Summers said he believes the owner of the cow he hit was not a tribal citizen, and another driver told the outlet the same thing — that the cow’s owner was not a tribal citizen. Neither account resolves the dispute, and the outcome of the pending case was not detailed in the sheriff’s statements.

Who's Responsible for Keeping Cattle Off the Road

The sheriff said handling loose animals, including cattle, falls under the sheriff’s office’s responsibility, while Oklahoma Highway Patrol handles the actual vehicle collisions with cows on highways. Deputies ask owners to secure their cattle and can issue fines if the problem continues, the sheriff said.

OHP told the outlet that troopers respond to reports of livestock on roads and try to return the animals behind a fence while also trying to identify the owner. That is not always simple — troopers may not know exactly where an animal came from when multiple pastures sit nearby.

Summers said cattle owners are responsible for keeping their cattle off the roads in the first place. Oklahoma law requires domestic livestock to be restrained and prohibits the animals from roaming at large, according to the Official Oklahoma Statutes, which also state that damages caused by domestic animals trespassing on another’s land are to be recovered in a manner provided by law. The statute is a general restraint requirement, not a determination of fault in any specific crash on Highway 9.

A Separate Cattle Scare Elsewhere in the State

Loose cattle on Oklahoma roads made headlines elsewhere too. On October 30, a cattle hauler overturned near mile marker 208 on Interstate 35 in Kay County, killing some of the calves it was carrying while others escaped onto the highway and into surrounding areas, according to News 9. Oklahoma Highway Patrol said five local cowboys responded without hesitation, roping and securing the escaped animals.

For drivers along Highway 9 near Raiford, loose cattle remain a concern. The sheriff has said owners should secure their animals, and the matter involving Summers’ crash was turned over to the Muscogee Nation.