Cleveland/ Crime & Emergencies

Lorain Officer Indicted on Gun Theft Charge About a Month After Menacing Conviction

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 19, 2026
Lorain Officer Indicted on Gun Theft Charge About a Month After Menacing ConvictionLorain Police Department — Department Placing Officer On Leave
Google Street View

A 35-year-old Lorain police officer has been indicted on charges that he stole a Glock 19 handgun and violated a protection order, about a month after he was separately convicted of menacing in a Huron courtroom. Thomas Sheridan faces a third-degree felony charge of grand theft of a firearm and a first-degree misdemeanor charge of violating a protection order, both tied to a single day in July.

According to an indictment filed Nov. 12 in Erie County Common Pleas Court, as reported by cleveland.com, prosecutors allege Sheridan stole the handgun on July 16 and violated a protection order that same day. The indictment also alleges he had a firearm during the theft. Court records show Sheridan was arrested following the indictment, and a judge set his bond at $20,000 while ordering him to have no contact with any victims in the case or their families.

Under Ohio law, the grand theft charge carries extra weight specifically because of what was allegedly taken. The state’s theft statute, Ohio Revised Code Section 2913.02, states that if the property stolen is a firearm or dangerous ordnance, the offense is elevated to grand theft. The separate misdemeanor charge stems from Ohio’s protection-order statute, Section 2919.27, which covers violations of orders or consent agreements issued under several sections of state law. The Erie County case remains pending.

A Separate Menacing Case Already Resolved

The Erie County indictment follows a different, already-closed case in Huron Municipal Court. Sheridan pleaded no contest Sept. 29 to menacing and was found guilty Oct. 13, the station’s report notes. That case stemmed from a July 1 incident, and prosecutors requested dismissal of a separate charge of threatening domestic violence in connection with it.

For the menacing conviction, Sheridan received a 30-day suspended jail sentence, one year of supervised probation and a $250 fine. The court also ordered him to complete an anger management program and to have no contact with the victim for five years — a far longer no-contact window than the typical probationary period attached to the sentence.

Two Stints on Paid Leave

Sheridan’s recent legal troubles trace back to the spring, when he was placed on paid administrative leave April 28 while the Lorain Police Department conducted an internal investigation. The order stated that the leave was not a finding of wrongdoing. Police Chief Michael Failing ordered Sheridan to surrender his department-issued weapons, badge and vehicle, and barred him from police facilities.

Sheridan was placed on paid leave again July 2, after police learned of an incident at his residence that led to his arrest — the same stretch of time that produced both the menacing case and the conduct now charged in Erie County. He was again ordered to surrender department equipment and barred from police facilities following that second leave order.

A Winding Path Through the Department

Sheridan’s tenure with the Lorain Police Department has not been a straight line. He joined the department in November 2021 and became a permanent officer in November 2022. He resigned in November 2024, saying at the time that he planned to attend flight school, but returned to the department in October 2025, according to his personnel file.

Lorain Human Resources Director Lori Kokoski confirmed that Sheridan is a full-time police officer but said she did not know whether he remains on paid leave. Lorain police spokesperson Jacob Morris did not immediately answer the same question when asked.

Attorney Says Sheridan Denies Wrongdoing

Sheridan’s attorney, Tyler Lantzsch, said his client unequivocally denies the charges and any wrongdoing associated with them. Lantzsch added that they look forward to the legal process and an opportunity for the whole truth to come out.