Los Angeles/ Politics & Govt

Los Angeles County Nurse Supervisor Fired Over Vaccine Faith Fight Nears Final Ruling

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 16, 2026
Los Angeles County Nurse Supervisor Fired Over Vaccine Faith Fight Nears Final RulingSource: jjron / Wikimedia Commons

Los Angeles County is pushing a judge to close the book on a former nursing supervisor's religious discrimination lawsuit, arguing the window for her to fix her dismissed complaint has already closed. Marilee Males, who once oversaw nursing operations at a Department of Health facility in El Monte, says she lost her job in 2023, just months before her retirement benefits would have vested, after she objected on religious grounds to the county's COVID-19 vaccination requirement. A hearing on the county's request is scheduled for Tuesday at Los Angeles Superior Court.

County Says the Clock Has Run Out

Los Angeles County is asking Judge Gary D. Roberts to enter immediate judgment in its favor, according to MyNewsLA.com, contending that the deadline for Males to file an amended complaint has expired. Roberts had already granted the county's motion to dismiss Males' suit on October 5. The county has also maintained that it is immune from liability on Males' claims, the outlet reports.

Males' attorneys are pushing back, arguing there is no immediate need to enter judgment and that the matter should instead proceed through ordinary motion practice, per the same report. They have also indicated that if judgment is entered, Males intends to appeal, saying she believes the dismissal of her case was wrong.

A Nearly Five-Year County Career Unraveled by a Vaccine Mandate

Males was hired by the county in May 2018 and worked as a supervising health facilities evaluator for nursing, a role in which she oversaw roughly 10 nurses and four secretaries while coordinating facility visits, reviewing survey reports, and addressing provider concerns, according to the MyNewsLA.com account. The job came with about $182,135 in annual pay and benefits. In September 2021, Males requested a religious exemption from the county's vaccine policy, writing that her objection relied on teachings in the Holy Bible.

That request came roughly on the heels of the county's vaccination mandate, which took effect October 1, 2021, according to the Los Angeles Times. By March 2022, Males had received a five-day suspension notice for allegedly not testing for the virus, despite claiming she had done so, and a separate five-day suspension advisement for failing to comply with the vaccination requirement itself, per the MyNewsLA.com report. She then sought reconsideration of the denial of her religious exemption, but the county denied that request in December 2022.

Fourteen Days, Then a Termination Letter

Males was given 14 calendar days to submit proof that she had received a first COVID-19 vaccine dose. When she did not, the county sent her a termination letter dated January 25, 2023, stating she was being let go for failing to comply with the vaccination requirement. Her attorneys say her retirement benefits would have vested just four months later, and that she would have received about $1,300 per month after retiring. Males filed suit in Los Angeles Superior Court in May 2023, alleging wrongful termination, religious creed discrimination, retaliation, failure to prevent discrimination and retaliation, and a labor code violation. In that filing, she reported suffering lost future earnings along with anxiety, nausea, insomnia, headaches, depression, and post-traumatic stress tied to losing her job.

How the County's Mandate Played Out Broadly

Males' case sits within a much larger wave of county personnel decisions during the pandemic. The county ultimately approved 7,359 vaccine-exemption requests and separated 68 employees for failing to comply with the policy, per the Los Angeles Times. By late December 2021, the county had already suspended roughly 900 employees and terminated four others for non-compliance or for failing to even submit exemption requests, according to prior Hoodline reporting on a related lawsuit. The county eventually ended its employee vaccination requirement entirely on April 3, 2023, ceasing to mandate shots for new hires or existing staff except where another government rule or order still applies.

Males is not the only county worker to challenge a vaccine-related firing in court. Jadon Josiah Knight, a longtime library employee, sued the county alleging he was fired in December 2022 after refusing a COVID-19 vaccine and being denied a religious exemption, filing his case in Los Angeles Superior Court on August 26, according to the same Hoodline report. His suit similarly alleges discrimination, harassment, retaliation, failure to accommodate, and failure to engage in the interactive process.

Mixed Outcomes in Similar Religious-Accommodation Disputes

Outcomes in comparable vaccine-exemption cases have varied widely elsewhere. In Lewis-Williams v. San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District, a jury rejected BART's undue-hardship defense and awarded six former employees a combined $7,824,580, a verdict the Ninth Circuit affirmed, according to California Employment Law Update. The appeals court applied the undue-hardship standard set out in Groff v. DeJoy and noted that while employers may ordinarily rely on public-health guidance, that guidance is not automatically conclusive — and BART, the report states, never introduced the specific guidance it relied on into the trial record.

Other cases have gone the opposite direction. The Ninth Circuit separately reversed dismissal of a religious-accommodation complaint against a California public employer in Bolden-Hardge v. State Controller's Office, holding that the plaintiff had adequately pleaded claims under Title VII and the state's Fair Employment and Housing Act, according to Cadry Law. And on the other side of the country, an Illinois county hospital pharmacy technician's COVID-vaccine bias case fell short in the Seventh Circuit, per Law360.

For now, Males' case remains unresolved. Tuesday's hearing will determine whether Judge Roberts grants the county's request for immediate judgment or allows her attorneys' objections to proceed through standard motion practice, with an appeal expected to follow if judgment is entered against her.