St. Louis/ Crime & Emergencies

Man Who Killed Maryville Pastor in 2009 Seeks Supervised Release, Hearing Set

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 16, 2026
Man Who Killed Maryville Pastor in 2009 Seeks Supervised Release, Hearing SetSource: Google Street View

The man who shot and killed Maryville pastor Fred Winters in front of his own congregation in 2009 is asking a judge to let him leave the grounds of Alton Mental Health Center under supervision. Terry Sedlacek, now 44, has a hearing scheduled for 10 a.m. Tuesday, Nov. 17, before Circuit Judge Kyle Napp, who will decide whether Sedlacek should be granted increased privileges, including supervised off-grounds release.

Sedlacek was found not guilty by reason of insanity in July 2015 for the killing of Winters, the pastor of First Baptist Church of Maryville, and was transferred into the custody of the Illinois Department of Health and Human Services that same month, according to The Telegraph. He has petitioned before for conditional release, transfer to a non-secure facility, or day passes, and those requests have all been denied, with the most recent one filed in early 2025, the outlet reports.

What Happened Inside the Church in 2009

On March 8, 2009, Sedlacek drove to the Maryville church and entered during Winters’ Sunday-morning sermon before firing several times inside the sanctuary. One shot struck Winters’ Bible, and another struck him in the chest, killing him, per the same account. Two parishioners who tackled Sedlacek suffered knife wounds in the struggle, and Sedlacek attempted to cut his own throat and survived.

In the aftermath, detectives searched Sedlacek’s home in Troy and found two 12-gauge shotguns, a rifle, bullets, and a document described as a “Last Day Will” written on an index card. Prosecutors charged him with two counts of murder and two counts of aggravated assault before the case ultimately resulted in the insanity finding six years later.

The Legal Path to Tuesday's Hearing

Illinois law governs what happens after a defendant is acquitted by reason of insanity under a provision known as 730 ILCS 5/5-2-4, titled “Proceedings after Acquittal by Reason of Insanity,” according to the Illinois General Assembly. That statute is the framework under which Sedlacek’s latest bid for supervised off-grounds release will be heard this week.

Tuesday’s hearing will determine only whether Sedlacek receives increased privileges at this stage of his treatment. The community will be watching closely, given the repeated denials of his past requests and the lasting impact of Winters’ killing on the Maryville congregation.