
Massachusetts could soon stop treating 18-year-olds like adults in the eyes of the criminal justice system — at least for most offenses. The state Senate has passed an amendment from Democratic state Sen. Brendan Creighton that would send 18-year-olds through the juvenile system rather than adult criminal court for the bulk of charges they might face.
According to WBZ NewsRadio 1030, the Senate recently passed Creighton's Raise the Age amendment, which would send 18-year-olds to juvenile prison for most crimes. The measure now heads to the House, which has until early January to take it up. Creighton has framed the change around how the teenage brain works, arguing that an 18-year-old's decision making can still be impulsive and that the policy should move forward if the evidence backs it up.
Creighton also pointed to the long shadow a criminal record can cast over a young person's future. “Getting a job, buying a home, getting loans. This record will trail you for quite a long time,” he said, per the same WBZ report. He has stressed the amendment is not meant to be a free pass, telling the station it is not a get-out-of-jail-free card for serious offenders.
What the Amendment Does and Doesn't Cover
Under the proposal, the expanded juvenile jurisdiction would not reach the most serious cases. Creighton told WBZ that the amendment isn't for serious, violent crimes, a limit meant to address concerns that the change would sweep in dangerous offenders alongside lower-level ones. Still, critics of the amendment have pushed back, saying they're hesitant to let older offenders off the hook, according to the same station.
Beyond the current debate, Creighton has pointed to the Department of Youth Services as offering more education, mental health treatment, and job training resources than the adult criminal justice system, a claim he made in earlier remarks reported by CommonWealth Beacon. That outlet also notes that after Massachusetts raised the age of criminal majority in 2013 to bring many 17-year-olds into the juvenile system, arrests of people younger than 18 fell by more than half, according to data compiled by Citizens for Juvenile Justice. Supporters argue recidivism rates are significantly lower for people who go through the Department of Youth Services than for those processed in adult court, per the outlet's reporting.
A Familiar Fight in the Senate
This isn't the first time lawmakers have tried to make this change. The Senate approved a similar raise-the-age amendment in 2024 by a 31-9 vote, CommonWealth Beacon reports. Lawmakers had also weighed a similar shift years earlier but ultimately dropped it from a sweeping criminal justice bill passed in 2018, according to The Boston Globe.
Looking at Vermont's Experience
Massachusetts isn't alone in considering this approach. Vermont's own Raise the Age law began to take effect in 2020, routing young adults charged with most offenses into juvenile delinquency proceedings instead of adult criminal court, according to VTDigger. Vermont's version still sends people accused of serious crimes such as murder, kidnapping, and sexual assault to adult criminal court, the outlet notes — a structure echoing Creighton's stated exclusion for serious, violent offenses.
A report on 377 Vermont 18-year-olds whose cases moved through Family Division courts found reconviction rates of 6.9% after one year and 18.7% after three years among the 160 cases with longer observation windows, per VTDigger. That compares with a separate 2022 baseline report finding that 24% of 18- and 19-year-olds processed through adult criminal court were reconvicted within one year and 46% within three years. VTDigger cautions, however, that the two groups were studied over distinct periods and selected for observation using somewhat different criteria, so the figures shouldn't be read as a direct before-and-after comparison.
For now, the fate of Creighton's amendment rests with the Massachusetts House, which WBZ reports has until early January to act. Whether lawmakers there take up the measure — and what, if anything, changes before then — remains to be seen.









