Miami Valley/ Health & Lifestyle

Mercy Health Patients Face Jan. 1 Coverage Cliff In Medical Mutual Standoff

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 19, 2026
Mercy Health Patients Face Jan. 1 Coverage Cliff In Medical Mutual StandoffSource: Ohio Office of Redevelopment / Wikimedia Commons

Mercy Health patients in Springfield and Urbana who carry Medical Mutual of Ohio coverage are being told to pay close attention to their mail and their insurance cards this winter. With the two organizations' current contract set to expire Dec. 31 and no new deal in hand, Mercy Health's physicians, hospitals and care sites across Ohio could become out-of-network for Medical Mutual members starting Jan. 1, 2027.

Negotiations between the health system and insurer began earlier in 2026 and, as of Nov. 18, had not produced an agreement, according to businessjournaldaily.com. Mercy Health has pointed to friction over money owed for care already delivered, saying it has “significant concerns about excessive denials and unpaid claims” under the existing contract, as reported by WFMJ. The health system has also said those payment obligations must be addressed before a renewal becomes possible.

Who Could Be Affected and When

The potential fallout touches a broad swath of Medical Mutual's membership in Ohio. Affected patients include people with Medical Mutual commercial or employer-sponsored plans, as well as Medicare Advantage and Exchange plans, and depending on their specific plan, they could face higher out-of-pocket costs or reduced coverage for nonemergency care, per the same account cited by WKBN.

For now, nothing changes. Mercy Health remains in-network with Medical Mutual through Dec. 31, and the station's report notes patients should keep seeing their Mercy Health providers and keep scheduled appointments as usual. But if the Dec. 31 deadline passes without a new contract, appointments scheduled for Jan. 1 or later for patients with Medical Mutual coverage may need to be rescheduled, and Mercy Health may also stop scheduling new appointments for those patients altogether.

A System-Wide Footprint

Mercy Health serves communities across Ohio and Kentucky through hospitals, medical practices and care sites, and locally that includes Mercy Health-Springfield Regional Medical Center, located at 100 Medical Center Dr. in Springfield, plus facilities in Urbana. The health system is part of Bon Secours Mercy Health, a Catholic health ministry that operates across the United States, Ireland and the Philippines.

Jeffrey Bross, speaking on behalf of Mercy Health, said patients should be able to focus on their health and treatment from care teams they know and trust. He added that Mercy Health remains committed to reaching a resolution but must be transparent with patients about possible network changes and the actions they may need to take, according to the Dayton Daily News.

Continuity of Care and Emergency Options

Some patients in the middle of ongoing treatment may be able to continue with their Mercy Health care team at in-network benefit levels for a period of time through a process known as continuity of care. That option is not automatic, however, and requires approval from Medical Mutual of Ohio. Patients are being urged to call the number on the back of their insurance card to find out whether they qualify and what documentation may be required, while also contacting Medical Mutual directly to understand potential coverage and cost changes beginning Jan. 1.

Regardless of how negotiations shake out, Mercy Health says emergency care will continue to be available regardless of network status, a point also emphasized by WFMJ. Mercy Health says it is providing updates, including frequently asked questions and patient guidance, at mercy.com. WKBN reported that it reached out to Medical Mutual of Ohio for comment but had not received a response at the time of its report.

Part of a Broader Ohio Pattern

Mercy Health's standoff with Medical Mutual is not an isolated case in Ohio this year. Cleveland Clinic has said some patients with certain Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield plans will no longer be in-network starting Jan. 1, 2027, while Kettering Health has said it will go out of network with Anthem Medicare Advantage in 2027, according to earlier Hoodline reporting. Preliminary research from a Brown University researcher cited in that coverage found that about one in five hospitals had at least one public dispute with an insurer between June 2021 and May 2025, with roughly 8% going out of network with an insurer they were negotiating with for at least some stretch of time. An estimate cited by NBC News, referenced in the same report, puts the number of such public disputes nationwide at 500 to 600 each year.

Under Ohio's administrative rules, insurers are required to notify enrollees who received care from a provider or facility within the previous 12 months if that provider's network participation expires or terminates, according to Ohio Administrative Code Rule 3901-8-16. For Mercy Health patients watching the calendar tick toward Dec. 31, that notice requirement may be the first concrete signal of whether this dispute gets resolved — or whether they'll need to make other arrangements come January.