Milwaukee/ Crime & Emergencies

Milwaukee Hospital Guard Stabbed After Suspect Sent to ER Alone, Gets $180K

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 17, 2026
Milwaukee Hospital Guard Stabbed After Suspect Sent to ER Alone, Gets $180KAscension Columbia St. Mary’s Hospital — Reported Emergency-Room Stabbing Site
Google Street View

A security officer at Ascension Columbia St. Mary’s in Milwaukee says he helped detain a man who threatened him and his colleagues in a hospital parking structure, only to be stabbed less than an hour later when that same man was sent into the emergency department without a police escort. Sedric A. Smith has now settled his federal lawsuit against the City of Milwaukee stemming from the January 2024 attack, closing out a case that accused police of leaving him and hospital staff exposed to danger they had already flagged.

A $180,000 Settlement Ends the Federal Case

The lawsuit was settled on Dec. 11, 2025, for $180,000, according to Wisconsin Law Journal. Smith had filed suit in the Eastern District of Wisconsin against the City of Milwaukee and the officers who responded to the parking structure incident on Jan. 29, 2024. He alleged that he helped detain a man who had threatened him and his colleagues, setting off a chain of events that he says police mishandled from the start.

According to the outlet’s reporting, responding Milwaukee police officers found a knife in the man’s backpack during the parking structure encounter. Despite that discovery, officers sent the man by ambulance to the same hospital’s emergency department without a police escort, without seizing the knife, without warning hospital staff and without invoking an emergency detention under Chapter 51, the lawsuit alleged. Less than an hour later, the man stabbed Smith multiple times in the emergency room restroom.

Injuries and the Legal Claims at the Center of the Case

Smith suffered a right upper back and posterior neck laceration requiring seven sutures, a scalp laceration requiring four staples, and a left forearm laceration, per the same account. He also suffered emotional distress. Those injuries formed the factual backbone of a lawsuit that combined constitutional and state-law theories against both the city and the individual officers involved.

Smith asserted Fourteenth Amendment state-created-danger and failure-to-protect claims, arguing that police actions put him in a worse position than if they had never intervened at all. He also brought a Monell failure-to-train claim against the City of Milwaukee, along with a standard negligence claim. Attorney Emil Ovbiagele of AxePoint Law in Milwaukee represented Smith in the lawsuit.

What State Law Says About Emergency Detention Training

Wisconsin law does set out training expectations tied to the kind of emergency detention power Smith’s lawsuit says officers failed to use. Under Wisconsin Statutes § 51.15, law enforcement agencies are required to designate at least one officer authorized to take an individual into custody under the statute, and that officer must attend in-service training on emergency detention and emergency protective placement procedures. The provision speaks to the broader legal framework at issue in the case but does not itself resolve how the responding officers in Smith’s incident were trained or what specific actions they took that night.

No court docket, complaint, or settlement agreement has been made available to independently verify the full scope of the parties’ allegations or the precise terms of the payout beyond the $180,000 figure reported. The identities of the responding officers and details from any police report or hospital record have not been disclosed in available reporting. What is documented is the outcome: a federal lawsuit filed over a violent attack inside a hospital emergency room, resolved more than a year and a half later with a six-figure settlement from the City of Milwaukee.