Minneapolis/ Crime & Emergencies

Minnesota Brothers Demand Grave Be Dug Up in Alleged 3-Body Funeral Home Mix-Up

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 20, 2026
Minnesota Brothers Demand Grave Be Dug Up in Alleged 3-Body Funeral Home Mix-UpBeltrami County District Court — Court Handling Exhumation Petition
Google Street View

Two brothers in Minnesota are asking a judge to let them dig up their brother's grave, alleging that the man they buried on May 21 may not be Brian Fairbanks at all. Fairbanks died April 9 at age 31, and his family says they held a closed-casket graveside service believing his remains were inside the casket lowered into the ground at Sugar Bush Cemetery. Two days later, according to a sworn statement cited in their petition, that casket was pulled back out of the earth and replaced with another.

A Relative's Account of a Casket Swap

The petition, filed Nov. 3, says Fairbanks' aunt saw workers remove a black metal casket from his grave on May 23 and place a brown wooden one in its stead, according to court documents cited by Valley News Live. She was reportedly told the black casket had contained the wrong body. The family says all of this unfolded without their knowledge, and they are now asking the court to let them exhume the grave to find out whose remains were actually buried there — and where Brian Fairbanks' body might be.

The alleged swap traces back to a funeral held two counties over. Herbert Libby Jr. was to be buried in a black casket on May 23, 2026, but when mourners gathered in White Earth, a funeral attendee recognized the man inside as 70-year-old Donald Bohn, who had died May 13 and was supposed to have been cremated, according to the Star Tribune. Libby's family realized he was not inside the casket meant for his service.

Three Families, One Funeral Home

A black casket was delivered to the Libby family on May 24, and this time, the family insisted on opening it themselves before the service could proceed. Per the same account, they confirmed Herbert Libby Jr.'s body was inside. By then, a member of the Bohn family had already picked up what was purported to be Donald Bohn's cremated remains — at 11:21 a.m. on May 22, a day before Bohn was reportedly seen in the wooden casket at Libby's funeral. The petition poses the question directly: whose ashes did Amber Bohn receive, and where is Brian Fairbanks' body — questions the family says only an exhumation of Fairbanks' grave can answer.

All three families used Northern Peace Funeral Home in Walker, Minnesota, to handle arrangements, according to court documents. The funeral home has not responded to a request for comment from KARE 11, and the Star Tribune reported separately that the business's owners and their attorney did not respond to requests for comment either. Minnesota's Department of Health disciplinary-results page lists a Northern Peace Administrative Penalty Order, though the underlying details and date of that order are not specified on the page.

Court Puts Exhumation Request on Hold

The allegations laid out in the petition have not been tested or confirmed by the court, and it remains unclear who is actually buried in Fairbanks' grave or whose cremated remains the Bohn family received, per the Star Tribune's reporting. A judge has put the exhumation request on hold pending notice to relatives and the other two families, and another hearing is scheduled for Dec. 14 at 2:30 p.m., according to Valley News Live.

Fairbanks' family has asked that the petition be expedited, saying they want any exhumation to happen before the ground freezes deep this winter. Under Minnesota law, an exhumation can proceed either with the consent of the surviving legal next of kin or by order of the district court in the county where the body is buried, according to the Minnesota Revisor of Statutes, with notice given as the court directs. For now, Brian Fairbanks' brothers are left waiting for a court date, and for an answer to the question that has haunted them since the spring: whose grave have they been visiting all along?