Boston/ Crime & Emergencies

MIT Brothers Walk Free in $25 Million Ethereum Case After Judge Tosses Charges

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 17, 2026
MIT Brothers Walk Free in $25 Million Ethereum Case After Judge Tosses ChargesSource: Google Street View

A Manhattan federal judge acquitted brothers Anton and James Peraire-Bueno on Monday, clearing the MIT-educated pair of wire fraud and related charges stemming from allegations they siphoned roughly $25 million worth of cryptocurrency off the Ethereum blockchain in about 12 seconds. The ruling ends a case that had already survived one trial without a verdict, sparing the brothers from facing a jury a second time.

U.S. District Judge Jessica Clarke found that prosecutors had failed to show the brothers made material misrepresentations while carrying out their trading strategy, according to The Block. Clarke determined that the strategy the brothers used did not amount to criminal fraud under the statutes prosecutors had cited, the outlet reported. Bloomberg, which first reported Monday's acquittal, noted that Clarke specifically found the brothers had not lied in carrying out their scheme, allowing them to avoid a new trial, according to a Bloomberg report by Bob Van Voris published through Bloomberg.

How the Alleged Scheme Worked

Prosecutors had accused the brothers of exploiting a flaw tied to the Ethereum blockchain's trading infrastructure to pull in the $25 million haul in roughly 12 seconds, per Bloomberg's reporting. The Block's account of the case described the method in more detail: the brothers allegedly used bait transactions to manipulate other traders' automated sandwich bots before intercepting their trades. The brothers are MIT graduates, according to Bloomberg's reporting on their backgrounds.

The U.S. Department of Justice's original announcement of the arrest characterized the case as a novel scheme to exploit the integrity of the Ethereum blockchain itself. In a statement at the time, the U.S. Department of Justice said the indictment arose from an alleged scheme to fraudulently obtain approximately $25 million worth of cryptocurrency within approximately 12 seconds. That characterization reflected the government's allegation in the indictment, not a finding of guilt, and the case's outcome Monday underscores that distinction.

A Case That Already Survived One Trial

The brothers were arrested in May 2024 after prosecutors accused them of exploiting the Ethereum blockchain, the same outlet's reporting noted. Their case first went to trial and ended without resolution: a jury deadlocked and a mistrial was declared in Manhattan federal court in November 2025, roughly a year before Monday's acquittal. The brothers had appeared at federal court in New York on October 14, 2025, as the first trial proceeded, with photographer Christian Monterrosa capturing images of the pair outside the courthouse.

The Block also placed the case within a broader pattern of attacks on Ethereum's trading ecosystem, noting that in April 2023, a separate group of automated trading bots known as MEV bots lost more than $25 million in seconds during an earlier blockchain exploit. That episode is distinct from the Peraire-Bueno case but reflects the same kind of vulnerability in how trades are ordered and executed on the Ethereum network that prosecutors had alleged the brothers took advantage of.

What Comes Next

With Monday's acquittal, Anton and James Peraire-Bueno will not face a second trial on the wire fraud charges that had hung over them since their 2024 arrest. No appeal status or further court proceedings have been reported following the acquittal. The case stands as a rare instance of a blockchain-exploitation prosecution ending not in a plea or conviction, but in a judge's determination that the alleged conduct did not meet the legal bar for criminal fraud.