
Three adults in Monongalia County are facing criminal charges after detectives say false information about a child's medical condition led to an invasive surgery that investigators consider medically unnecessary. The Monongalia County Sheriff's Office says the case began Oct. 8, after concerns surfaced about discrepancies in a child's reported medical history and the overall welfare of two children.
According to WV MetroNews, the investigation grew out of concern for the children's well-being and questions about whether a child's reported medical needs matched reality. Emilee Guzman has been charged with felony child neglect resulting in serious bodily injury, while Caitlin Jean Meredith and Milton Alexander Guzman Cisneros were each charged with two counts of child neglect creating risk of bodily injury, the station reports. Detectives allege that inaccurate statements about the child's medical conditions and nutritional needs contributed to the child undergoing an invasive surgical procedure they say was medically unnecessary.
How Detectives Built the Case
Investigators say they reviewed extensive medical records, interviewed numerous medical professionals, executed search warrants and examined digital evidence as part of the inquiry, per the same account. That work, detectives say, ultimately led to a diagnosis of medical child abuse.
The Dominion Post reports that a child-abuse pediatrician diagnosed the case as medical child abuse, a condition commonly known as Munchausen syndrome by proxy. Detectives also reported finding evidence of ongoing neglect involving both children, including hazardous and unsanitary living conditions, according to the outlet. The sheriff's office emphasized that all defendants are presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty in a court of law, the paper notes.
Lawmakers Eye New Criminal Statute
The case has already drawn the attention of state lawmakers. According to WTAP, legislators said they intend to introduce a bill in the 2027 legislative session that would create a specific criminal offense for medical child abuse. The proposal would target anyone who knowingly makes up, lies about or hides medical information that leads to unnecessary medical treatment or a medically substantiated risk of harm, the station reports.
West Virginia Watch reports that the proposed legislation is expected to include safeguards for good-faith reporting, legitimate family advocacy, disagreements with physicians and medically appropriate care, according to West Virginia Watch. The outlet also notes that the 2027 legislative session is set to begin Jan. 13. No bill text has been introduced yet, and the measure is not current law.
A Bill That Failed Before
This would not be the first attempt at such a law. A prior legislative effort known as Raylee's Law did not pass during the 2026 session, according to WJAR, after last-minute procedural delays and amendments left no time for Senate concurrence before the midnight deadline, killing the bill.
West Virginia's existing code on child neglect creating risk of injury, West Virginia Code §61-8D-4, references a risk of death or serious bodily injury to a child. Prosecutors have not released charging documents or further statements on the case, and the children's current living arrangements have not been disclosed.
The case, first reported by WV MetroNews and later covered by CBS Pittsburgh as part of its coverage of the charges, has reignited attention on a disorder once widely known as Munchausen syndrome by proxy, now referred to clinically as factitious disorder imposed on another, according to the Cleveland Clinic. The condition is described as a mental health issue in which a caregiver lies about a person in their care needing medical attention, and in some instances may physically harm that person to produce symptoms or alter test results, per the clinic. The Cleveland Clinic also notes that the disorder is considered uncommon, that reliable statistics on how many people have it are not available, and that many cases go undetected.









