
An administrative law judge has ruled that Montclair Public Schools broke its own rules when it failed to keep proper seniority records before laying off and reassigning staff during a budget crisis last year. Judge Nanci G. Stokes found on Monday that the district never developed or maintained adequate seniority lists, and that it failed to recommend dismissals and transfers in accordance with those lists during its October 2025 reduction in force, violating its own policies.
The board’s Oct. 27, 2025, resolution said the superintendent had reviewed seniority for tenured, certificated and non-certificated staff and determined who would be eligible for reemployment or reassignment, transferred or terminated. It cited budgetary reasons and economy and efficiency as grounds for the reduction in force. That stated review makes the judge’s finding significant: the dispute concerned whether the district maintained usable seniority records and applied them, not simply whether it considered seniority in general. The board’s resolution set out those steps.
Stokes ordered the district to provide educators Lisa Rollins, Erica Daniel and Syreeta Carrington with their seniority status, according to Montclair Local. The three educators, along with Jennifer Bailey, had been reassigned to other positions through a process known as bumping, in which more senior employees displace those with less seniority. All four were caught up in the fallout from the district's reported $19 million deficit, which prompted the reduction in force approved by the school board in October 2025.
What the Educators Argued
Rollins, Daniel and Carrington each sought notification of where they stood on a seniority list, while Bailey initially sought reinstatement to her former position as a curriculum support teacher. The petitioners argued that the district violated tenure law by failing to provide affected employees a seniority-placement list, and they alleged that subsequent rehirings did not follow seniority rules.
New Jersey’s recall protection after a reduction in force is specific to tenured teaching staff: a dismissed tenured employee must remain on a preferred eligible list in seniority order and be rehired when a vacancy arises in a position for which that employee is qualified. State rules also provide standards for determining seniority. The statute’s focus on tenure and qualified vacancies helps explain why notice of seniority placement—and the unresolved question of later rehiring—matter separately in this dispute. The state’s explanation of the statute describes those protections.
Rollins said the district placed people based on favoritism rather than seniority, the outlet's report notes. Carrington called the ruling a vindication and said decisions made without following statutory language were arbitrary and capricious. Daniel, who also sought notification of her seniority-list placement, said the petition was about fairness.
The Curriculum Support Teacher Question Left Open
The ruling did not resolve everything the educators raised. Stokes did not decide whether the district followed seniority rules when it rehired nine curriculum support teachers as part of a board-approved reinstatement of 19 employees. She did describe the timing of those reinstatements as troubling, noting they preceded the effective reduction-in-force date without apparent seniority considerations, per the same account.
The district had argued that the seniority-notice requirement applied only to teachers who were actually fired, per the decision described in the report. Bailey, who later retired from teaching and forfeited her tenure status, was dismissed from the case as a result, according to court documents cited by the outlet. Bailey said she would still seek punitive damages.
Conflicting Numbers on the Layoffs
Accounts of the reduction in force's scale differ depending on when they were reported. The November 2026 report states the district terminated 98 employees, reassigned 50 and issued five reduction-in-force notices, while an October 2025 report from the same outlet described the cuts as affecting 103 staff members with 50 others reassigned. The deficit itself has also been described two ways, as $19 million in the more recent report and as $19.6 million in the earlier one. The board's own resolution, meanwhile, stated that the superintendent caused a review and assessment of seniority where applicable during the process, language that stopped short of the detailed accounting the judge later found lacking.
What Happens Next
The board had approved the reduction in force by an 8-0 vote at its Oct. 27, 2025 meeting, authorizing staff reductions, transfers and rescinded appointments for the 2025-26 school year. The educators' appeal was originally filed with the New Jersey Department of Education in February 2026 and transferred to the Office of Administrative Law the following month. Under state law, the commissioner holds jurisdiction to hear and determine controversies arising under the school laws, and the commissioner may still modify or reject Stokes' decision before issuing a final ruling.
The administrative law judge’s decision is generally an initial decision in a school-law dispute, not the last word: the Commissioner of Education reviews it and may adopt, reject or modify it. The Commissioner has 45 days from the filing of the initial decision to issue a final decision, subject to the applicable procedure; a final agency decision may then be appealed to the state Appellate Division. That process means the ruling’s administrative status depends on the Commissioner’s action. The Department of Education outlines the review process.
District communications director Eshaya Draper did not respond to a request for comment by press deadline, the outlet reported. Guidance from the New Jersey School Boards Association states that employees with seniority have recall rights in the order of their seniority. Stokes found that the district failed to maintain adequate seniority lists and recommend dismissals and transfers in accordance with them, but did not decide whether the later rehiring of nine curriculum support teachers followed seniority rules.









