
Napa's Planning Commission voted this week to recommend banning new and expanded drive-thrus along with new fossil-fuel gas stations citywide, sending the proposal to the City Council for a final decision. The commission backed the drive-thru ban 4-1 and approved the gas station prohibition unanimously at its meeting Thursday, with the changes folded into the city's broader zoning ordinance update.
Years in the Making
The vote marks the latest step in a debate that, according to The Press Democrat, traces back to 2021, when the Napa City Council denied a drive-thru component of the proposed Soscol Square Shopping Center at 333 Soscol Ave., which would have included a Raising Cane's restaurant. The council approved that project without the drive-thru, and construction never began. Napa Climate Now! had advocated for a drive-thru ban that same year as a way to combat climate change, the paper reports.
City staff have been studying the issue for a while. A City of Napa technical consistency memo dated January 2025 noted the existing zoning ordinance already requires a use permit for all drive-throughs, and it flagged an outright prohibition, citywide or in specific locations, as an option the city could consider. The same memo pointed to General Plan Policy CCS 2-1, which calls for alternatives to drive-through facilities that avoid sustained idling of fossil-fuel-powered engines.
What the Ban Would and Wouldn't Cover
Ryder Dilley, Napa's planning manager, said the proposed bans apply only to new facilities, with existing drive-thrus and gas stations exempt. Existing drive-thrus could still undergo improvements, Dilley said, just not expansion. City officials have described the proposed bans as intended to help Napa meet its climate goals.
Napa already took a related step in 2023, temporarily banning new fossil-fuel gas stations under a two-year interim zoning ordinance that expired in April 2025, according to the paper's reporting. That interim ordinance did not include any ban on new drive-thrus. The City of Napa's own memo described that 2023 measure as a moratorium on constructing new or expanding existing fossil-fuel service stations. New fossil-fuel gas stations are effectively banned throughout the rest of Napa County, the paper notes, and the broader trend has spread through the North Bay since Petaluma became the first U.S. town to prohibit new gas stations in 2021, according to Grist, which reported that bans then spread throughout Sonoma and Napa counties.
Commissioners Split on Convenience Versus Land Use
Commissioner Lisa Massaro said at the meeting that Napa already has plenty of drive-thrus and that they will remain under the proposed rules. Commissioner Lindsay Owen argued that curbside pickup and other options make drive-thrus a less necessary use of land, saying, “things have changed,” and noting that restaurants may provide curbside delivery to customers, including people with toddlers in car seats.
Commissioner Eryn Ebach said drive-thrus can undermine community connection and that the land they occupy has better uses. “I can't speak to the environmental side, that's not my area of expertise, but I have a strong opinion in terms of whether or not they are the highest and best use of land in most cases, and my argument is that they are not,” Ebach said.
Commissioner Alex Myers cast the lone vote against the drive-thru ban, arguing research does not show that drive-thru bans substantially reduce emissions and that drive-thru services provide access and convenience. “When I had three children in car seats in the car, I couldn't take them into a place but also couldn't leave them in a car,” Myers said at the meeting.
Part of a Statewide Pattern
Napa isn't alone in revisiting drive-thru rules. In Southern California, Carson's City Council unanimously approved the first reading of an ordinance tightening restrictions on new restaurant drive-thrus on Nov. 17, according to the Daily Breeze. That proposal, built around 16 new restrictions from city staff, would bar new drive-thru restaurant developments within 500 feet of an existing or approved one and would not apply to existing drive-thrus unless a modification is proposed. Carson officials cited traffic congestion and collision risks involving motorists, pedestrians and bicyclists as reasons for the tightened rules.
Napa's zoning update, meanwhile, is meant to align the city's rules with its 2040 General Plan, with public review and adoption of the new code expected sometime this year, per the Press Democrat's earlier reporting. Napa's rules could end up closer to Calistoga's, where drive-thrus are permitted only for financial institutions, though the city's commissioners have stopped short of that model so far. The Napa Planning Commission's recommendation now goes to the City Council, which will weigh the proposed drive-thru and gas station bans as part of the zoning ordinance update at a future meeting.









