
Villa Inn owners Marcello and Stephanie Fonio now want to build a second hotel just one block away. They have proposed a 50-room property called the San Rafael Inn and Suites at 1580 Lincoln Ave., the former site of a garden center, and the project is currently under review by the city's planning division.
The Fonios already co-own Villa Inn at 1600 Lincoln Ave. along with Cafe Villa next door, according to the Marin Independent Journal. Marcello Fonio Sr. remains involved in Villa Inn, per the outlet's reporting, while his son, Marcello Fonio Jr., is leading the push for the new project and seeking variances to reduce the required front and side yard setbacks as well as the number of parking spaces the city would otherwise mandate.
The city's own project page describes the proposal in more detail, calling it a boutique hotel with 50 guestrooms and amenities including a fitness room, a boardroom, a second-floor guest patio overlooking Lincoln Avenue, and an outdoor pet area. The San Rafael project page states plainly: “The proposed project (Project) is the San Rafael Inn and Suites a boutique hotel with 50 guestrooms and amenities including a fitness room, boardroom, second floor guest patio overlooking Lincoln Avenue, and an outdoor pet area.”
A Boutique Hotel Designed With Interior Corridors
The San Rafael Inn and Suites is planned as a boutique hotel with interior corridors and would stand four stories high, which Fonio Jr. says would put it about 12 feet above the residential-building height limit. The site is zoned for apartments, but the outlet's report notes that, per Fonio Jr., the zoning also allows hotels there.
An existing office building at 1817 Grand Ave. is part of the project and would remain largely intact with only minor modifications, housing the hotel's administrative offices. Fonio Jr. told the paper the new hotel would compete with the AC Hotel by Marriott and Embassy Suites, both already established players in San Rafael's lodging market.
Parking and Setback Variances at the Center of the Request
San Rafael's code typically requires one parking space per hotel guest room, but the proposed hotel would provide just 38 spaces for its 50 rooms. Fonio Jr. said the city allows developers to submit a traffic-engineer report supporting fewer spaces than the code otherwise demands.
A separate parking study by Hexagon Transportation Consultants Inc. examined seven Bay Area hotels ranging from 56 to 173 rooms. Those properties averaged 108 occupied rooms and 81 occupied parking spaces, for an average parking-demand ratio of 0.75 spaces per occupied room, according to a document filed on CEQAnet, whose Table 1 names and locates the hotels studied.
Any variance request in California must clear a specific legal bar. Under Government Code section 65906, variances may be granted only when special circumstances apply to the property and strict enforcement of the zoning ordinance would deprive it of privileges enjoyed by other properties in the vicinity under identical zoning.
A Public Cafe Separate From Cafe Villa
The city's project page describes a first-floor cafe at the new hotel that would be open to the public, separate from Cafe Villa next door.
Rising Rates Fuel Marin's Hotel Market
The proposal arrives as Marin County's lodging sector shows signs of strength. Robert Eyler projected in an August presentation that county hotel occupancy rates and average daily rates would steadily climb through 2028, and he has said the average daily rate in Marin County rose by $23.73 over the 12 months through September. Gina Marr-Hiemstra, chief executive officer of the Marin Convention and Visitors Bureau, said new boutique hotel projects can add character to the county's tourism offerings and benefit the broader community.
The San Rafael Inn and Suites remains a proposal moving through the planning division, with the Fonio family hoping to expand their presence on Lincoln Avenue.









