
A three-story building in downtown Middletown that has stood since 1831 just changed hands through an unusual sales method: an absolute auction with bidding that opened at a single dollar. The former U.S. Hotel at 34 S. Main St. carries ties to one of the city's most prominent industrialists and represents a piece of Middletown's early commercial history.
Bidding on the property opened at noon on Tuesday and was scheduled to close Thursday afternoon, according to Local 12. Because it was listed as an absolute auction, the building was guaranteed to go to the highest bidder no matter the final sale price. The station, a news partner of the Cincinnati Business Courier, reported on the sale as the clock wound down on the three-day bidding window.
A Building With Roots Stretching Back to 1831
The listing for the property, posted by Marcus & Millichap, describes a three-story, 29,492-square-foot historic building sitting on a 0.24-acre parcel. According to the listing, it was originally constructed in 1831 as a coffee house and residence before being converted into the U.S. Hotel in 1845. Its most recent use, per the same listing, was as a mixed-use building with retail space at street level and residences on the upper floors.
The property is identified in the listing as a contributing structure within a National Register Historic District. That status, the listing notes, creates potential eligibility for historic preservation tax credits for a future owner looking to rehabilitate the space.
Zoning Opens the Door to Multiple Uses
The site carries UC-C, or Urban Center Core, zoning, which the listing says permits a wide range of potential redevelopment paths, including hotel, office, retail, multifamily residential, mixed-use, and live-work concepts. The listing also points to the surrounding market, citing a five-mile trade area of 81,831 residents and 33,799 households.
Thomas Seaman is named in the listing as the auctioneer overseeing the sale, with a license number of 2007000016 attached to the listing. The auction format meant that whatever final bid emerged by Thursday afternoon's close would determine the building's new owner, with no reserve price to protect against a low sale.









