
Thomas Marshall tried to buy a handgun and a long gun for self-defense at his New Hampshire home in 2023, only to be turned away. The reason traced back decades: Massachusetts DUI convictions from 1997 and 2005 that the FBI flagged as federal disqualifiers under background check rules.
Marshall sued in June 2024, challenging the federal firearm prohibition as it applied to him, according to court records reviewed by courtlistener.com. He named Attorney General Todd Blanche, FBI Director Kashyap Pramod Patel, and ATF Director Robert Cekada as defendants, arguing that no relief mechanism existed in New Hampshire or under federal law without mounting an as-applied Second Amendment challenge. As reported by the Tampa Free Press, Marshall said he feared arrest, prosecution, incarceration, or a fine if he went through with the purchase anyway.
The New Hampshire State Police Permits and Licensing Unit had rejected his application after the FBI background check surfaced the old convictions. Under 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1), the federal ban covers people convicted of crimes punishable by more than one year in prison, while federal law exempts state misdemeanors carrying maximum sentences of two years or less. Marshall's Massachusetts DUI offense was punishable by up to two-and-a-half years in prison — six months beyond that exemption threshold, which is what triggered the disqualification.
Dismissal, Then a Reversal
U.S. District Judge Paul J. Barbadoro dismissed Marshall's lawsuit in June 2025, finding that his repeated drunk driving constituted ongoing reckless conduct and a serious community threat. That ruling leaned in part on United States v. Torres-Rosario, a 2011 First Circuit precedent that limited individual challenges to the federal gun ban.
But the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit revived Marshall's lawsuit, vacating the dismissal and sending the case back to the district court in New Hampshire for further proceedings. The panel opinion was authored by Chief Judge David Barron, with Judges Sandra Lynch and Lara Montecalvo joining.
The panel found that Marshall had standing to challenge the federal background check system, since his 2023 purchase denial gave him grounds to sue. New Hampshire had at least 30 federally licensed firearm manufacturers at the time he tried to buy a gun. At the same time, the panel ruled that Marshall lacked standing to challenge the federal ban on gun possession alone — Chief Judge Barron noted that Marshall had not alleged an intent to possess a firearm actually shipped or transported in interstate or foreign commerce, a distinction tied to how § 922(g)(1) criminalizes possession of firearms moved through interstate or foreign commerce.
A New Legal Test Takes Hold
The reversal comes against the backdrop of a shifting legal landscape. The U.S. Supreme Court reshaped Second Amendment law in 2022 with its Bruen ruling, which requires gun restrictions to align with the nation's historical traditions rather than older balancing tests. The District Court had recognized Bruen as announcing a new analytical framework for these claims.
Since then, United States v. Levasseur replaced the 2011 Torres-Rosario precedent within the First Circuit in September, requiring judges to apply the Supreme Court's historical why-and-how test to individual Second Amendment challenges. On remand, the district court must now conduct that required historical analysis in Marshall's case.
The court must also weigh the effect of a Justice Department restoration program on Marshall's claim. The department rolled out regulations establishing an administrative pathway under 18 U.S.C. § 925(c) for people to apply for restoration of their firearm rights. Federal prosecutors reported in a court filing in February that the attorney general had granted relief to 22 applicants under the new process.
A Similar Fight Playing Out Elsewhere
Marshall's case isn't the only one testing how far DUI convictions can reach into federal firearm restrictions. In a separate case last month, the 3rd Circuit ruled 8-6 that the federal firearms ban could not constitutionally be applied to Edward Williams solely on the basis of his DUI convictions, according to firstpost.com.
Not every recent ruling has favored gun-rights claims, though. In an unrelated dispute involving New Hampshire gun owners arrested in Massachusetts, the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court upheld the state's nonresident firearm licensing scheme as facially consistent with the Second Amendment, per nhjournal.com.
For now, Marshall's case returns to the district court in New Hampshire, where judges must apply the newer historical test and sort out how the Justice Department's restoration program factors into his claim. Marshall has said he plans to try buying a firearm again.









