North Jersey/ Real Estate & Development

Nutley Victorian Sells for $1.75M, Shattering Township's Price Record

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 21, 2026
Nutley Victorian Sells for $1.75M, Shattering Township's Price Record189 Highfield Ln. — Approximate Site of Record-Setting Sale
Google Street View

A gut-renovated Victorian in Nutley's Yantacaw section just sold for $1.75 million, making it the highest-priced home ever sold in the township. The sale of 189 Highfield Lane closed on Oct. 30, capping a bidding process that drew roughly 100 visitors and four offers within weeks of hitting the market.

The circa-1900 Queen Anne Victorian was listed on Aug. 12 for $1,799,000 and went under contract within 30 days, according to Patch. The final sale price landed $49,000 below asking, per seed facts tied to NJ.com, which reported that listing agent Lisa Turek received calls almost immediately after the home hit the market, with many prospective buyers coming from New York City. The first offer arrived within a week, and Turek ultimately fielded four bids before accepting what she described as an offer with terms and price they could not resist.

Inside the Record-Setting Victorian

The home itself is a study in contrasts between old and new. Built in 1900 in the Queen Anne Victorian style, it was fully gutted, rebuilt and expanded in 2021, emerging with five bedrooms, four full bathrooms, one half-bath and nearly 5,200 square feet of living space, according to the listing site for 189 Highfield Lane. The property sits on a 0.46-acre lot measuring 100 by 200 feet, with 2025 annual taxes recorded at $29,114.

Despite the renovation, the house kept hallmarks of its Queen Anne roots — a style known for romanticism, asymmetry, ornamentation and gabled roofs, per the NJ.com seed reporting. The original front stairway remains intact alongside an added back staircase, and the home retains preserved or replicated moldings, a refurbished second-floor Juliet balcony and a wrap-around porch on the main level.

What the 2021 Addition Brought

The 2021 expansion added an office, an expanded kitchen, a formal living room and an extra bedroom, while doubling the size of the great room. Upstairs, roughly 2,000 square feet of third-floor space remains unfinished, leaving room for a future buyer to expand further. Out back, the yard features a rebuilt saltwater pool, a patio and full fencing — all within walking distance of downtown Nutley and nearby parks.

Breaking Nutley's Previous Price Ceiling

The sale eclipses what had been Nutley's high-water mark: a six-bedroom home built in 1913 with four full bathrooms and two half-baths that sold for $1.55 million. Patch reported that record was set in July with the sale of 225 Hillside Avenue, while NJ.com's reporting places the prior $1.55 million benchmark in June 2026 — accounts that differ on timing but agree on the price. Before that, Patch noted, 57 High Street sold for $1.3 million in 2024, a figure described at the time as Nutley's highest-ever sale.

Turek, who listed the home alongside Tony Verducci under the NJ Luxury Real Estate Group with Serhant, said the house sets the bar. Anthony Verducci Jr. told Patch that record sales like this one reflect the desirability of the town as much as the house itself. A third voice in the same Patch report, attributed to Rubino Ryder, cautioned that while one sale doesn't redraw the market overnight, it can influence how buyers and sellers view comparable larger homes going forward.

Nutley's Rising Appeal

The record sale lands against a backdrop of a still-modest overall market: Nutley's median home sale price was $655,000 in October 2026, according to New Jersey Realtors data cited in the seed reporting. But Turek and others see signs the township is becoming a magnet for buyers squeezed out of pricier neighbors. Buyers are getting priced out of nearby Montclair, and other Essex County towns are becoming more popular with homebuyers as a result, per the same seed reporting.

Turek said Verona has become hard to get into, and that Nutley is becoming similarly difficult — she expects it to become one of the next destination towns in Essex County. The township, which sits about 12 miles from New York City and is bordered by the Passaic River, Clifton, Bloomfield and Belleville, covers 3.4 square miles and is home to roughly 30,100 people, according to U.S. Census data referenced in the seed reporting.