
Oakland’s Chamber of Commerce, its CEO Barbara Leslie and board chair emeritus Zack Wasserman face a proposed $42,000 ethics penalty over allegations that the Chamber’s political committee, OakPAC, failed to disclose the sources of nearly $90,000 in contributions used against then-Councilmember Desley Brooks in her 2018 reelection campaign.
According to The Oaklandside, the city's Public Ethics Commission enforcement unit recommended that the Chamber's political committee, Leslie and Wasserman pay a penalty of $42,000 to resolve the case. Investigators allege OakPAC acted as an undisclosed intermediary for campaign contributions, channeling donor money through a separate committee, Oaklanders for Responsible Leadership, which campaigned against Brooks before she lost her reelection bid that year.
According to the report, 16 contributors supplied a total of $89,800 for the effort, but their identities were not disclosed until months after the election. Investigators say OakPAC reported the money under its own name instead of naming the people and organizations that provided it, conduct the commission described as “serious violations” of Oakland’s Campaign Reform Act.
How the Money Moved Without Names Attached
The Oaklandside identified four $10,000 contributors, all in real estate: Lane Partners, Best Bay Apartments, TMG Partners and Wilson Meany LP. The report also named Comcast, CCSAC, Foster Interstate and Argent Materials among contributors that each gave $5,000.
The Oaklandside reports that investigators found OakPAC was not required to report large contributions daily in the weeks before the 2018 election. Contributors were reportedly offered the option of giving after October 20, 2018, which delayed disclosure until after Brooks had lost. California expanded rules on earmarked contributions that year; investigators say the arrangement avoided requirements for identifying major donors in campaign advertisements.
Chamber Leaders Say They Misread a New Law
Leslie and Wasserman told investigators they did not know about the newly amended state law on earmarked contributions and would not have solicited donations this way had they understood the requirements, The Oaklandside reported. Wasserman said the Chamber “inadvertently misunderstood the requirements of a newly amended state law and has since strengthened our compliance practices,” and said it remained committed to transparency, accountability and compliance. The outlet reported that Leslie declined an interview request.
The proposed settlement is on a no-contest basis: the respondents would accept the penalty without admitting the allegations, according to The Oaklandside. The commission has investigated the case since 2022 and is scheduled to consider the proposed settlement next week.
Part of a Larger Investigation Into the 2018 Race
The Chamber's case forms part of a broader investigation into the 2018 campaign against Brooks that also implicated former Mayor Libby Schaaf. In a related settlement reached in October 2024, Schaaf agreed to pay a $21,000 ethics fine as part of a package that assigned roughly $325,000 in penalties to two political committees, Oaklanders for Responsible Leadership and the Committee for an Affordable East Bay.
At the commission's September 2024 meeting, members voted 3-2 on a proposal about campaign contribution limits, according to minutes from the City of Oakland Public Ethics Commission.
What State Law Requires of Campaign Intermediaries
The allegations concern California Political Reform Act requirements for contributions made through intermediaries. Under section 84302, an intermediary or agent must provide the recipient with the true source’s name, address, occupation and employer, according to the Fair Political Practices Commission. The text of AB 249, filed with the California Legislative Information database, incorporates section 84302 intermediary-disclosure requirements for earmarked contributions.
How Oakland and State Regulators Handle Disclosure Cases
Oakland’s Charter authorizes the Public Ethics Commission to investigate, audit disclosure compliance and hold public hearings; the same section also sets out subpoena and penalty powers, according to the City of Oakland Charter. A separate California State Senate race in 2010 offers another example of regulators examining concealed sources: an FPPC accusation alleged that Rabbi Nachum Shifren and his committee concealed contribution sources. The cited memo describes allegations, not a final finding.
Whether the Public Ethics Commission approves the proposed $42,000 settlement next week remains to be seen. For now, the case stands as the latest reminder of how the 2018 campaign against Brooks continues to generate scrutiny of Oakland's political money trail years after she left office.









