
A murder trial got underway this week for an Ocala man accused of killing a 32-year-old English woman whose body was discovered partially clothed in a shallow grave in a wooded part of Marion Oaks. Dwain Hall, 54, is charged with first-degree murder and kidnapping in the death of Sonia Exelby, and opening statements along with the first witness testimony began on Tuesday as prosecutors laid out what they say led to her killing.
According to WCJB, prosecutors said Exelby flew from England to Florida on October 10, 2025, and that Hall had instructed her to bring $4,000 in cash. Her body was found in Marion County on October 17, 2025, according to the BBC, which also reported that Exelby, from Portsmouth, was 32 years old — though a Court TV account of the case lists her age as 33, a detail that remains unresolved between the two reports. The Ocala Star-Banner reports that Assistant State Attorney Amy Berndt spent 27 minutes detailing Exelby's life and the events prosecutors say led to her death.
Hall has previously pleaded not guilty to the charges, the station's report notes. A defense attorney told jurors Tuesday that the evidence would show “Dwain Hall did not murder this woman,” pushing back directly against the state's narrative as the trial opened.
How Prosecutors Say the Two Met
Prosecutors said Hall and Exelby had been in contact for about two years through Motherless.com, as well as through an encrypted messaging application called Sessions, according to The News (Portsmouth). That outlet also reported that prosecutors will not seek the death penalty in Hall's case, a detail that frames the stakes jurors are weighing as they hear testimony.
Per the same account out of WCJB, the trial is expected to include roughly 15 witnesses as the state builds its case. Reporting from the station describes prosecutors presenting both purchase records and cellphone-location evidence, including what investigators say were two kinds of rope, gun oil, deodorant, and a shovel bought before Exelby's death.
Family Testimony and Trial Timeline
Exelby's sister testified about a planned visit as the trial continued, as reported by WFTV. The Telegraph reported that the trial is set to last four days, with jurors expected to begin deliberations on Friday.
Hall remains charged with first-degree murder and kidnapping as testimony continues in the Marion County courtroom.









