Central Massachusetts/ Family & Kids

Old Northampton Church Reborn as Kids' Play Cafe After Years of Shifting Plans

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 19, 2026
Old Northampton Church Reborn as Kids' Play Cafe After Years of Shifting PlansHawley St. — Approximate Site of Planned Play Cafe
Google Street View

A church that has sat empty on Hawley Street in Northampton since 2010 is finally getting new life, not as apartments or a restaurant, but as a place for toddlers to climb, build and make crafts. Melisa Grandison and Sarah Gray plan to open WillowRoot Collective, a cafe paired with an indoor children's play space, inside the former St. John Cantius Church, with hopes of welcoming families by spring 2027.

According to MassLive, the building has stood vacant since 2010, and the 6,500-square-foot space will house a cafe at the front with a children's play area behind it. The play area is designed for children as young as infants and as old as 8, with plans for climbing or swinging structures, a building zone and an arts and crafts area. Notably, a 2023 MassLive report on earlier renovation work at the same address described it as a 6,200-square-foot building, a discrepancy that remains unresolved between the two accounts.

The cafe itself will be open to anyone, not just families with young kids, and WillowRoot intends to turn the space into a board game cafe several evenings each week, with games on offer for teenagers as well. Families will be able to purchase a membership or a day pass to access the play area, though the business has not yet announced any prices for memberships, day passes or cafe items.

A Church's Long and Winding Redevelopment Story

The building's path to becoming a play space has been anything but straightforward. The Roman Catholic Diocese of Springfield sold the property to O'Connell Development Group in early 2020, and the developer went on to demolish a former rectory on the site and build townhouses in its place.

O'Connell originally planned a restaurant for the church building itself, but the pandemic changed the dining industry, according to Sarah Stine, president of O'Connell Development Group, as the same outlet's reporting notes. The developer later proposed demolishing the church building but ran into community opposition, before eventually putting the structure on the market for a business to rent. Stine said the WillowRoot project is a good fit for the building and the neighborhood, per the report.

From Pop-Ups to a Permanent Home

Grandison and Gray found the church with the help of broker Erica Swallow, and the pair bring professional backgrounds in education to the venture. They also have four children of their own, ages 2, 4, 5 and 7, and have said they're seeking to create a welcoming space for queer and interracial families — a framing echoed in a Northampton.live event listing describing WillowRoot as an indoor play space by day and a queer-centered board game cafe by night.

Before signing on to the church space, the founders tested their concept with several pop-up events over the summer on Strong Avenue, which closes to traffic during warmer months. Denise Lopez Medina, who attended one of the pop-ups, said the event offered crafts, board games, toys and sensory experiences, and that her family was entertained for hours. She told the outlet she supported having a permanent local play space, and organizers reported that families who attended the pop-ups gave positive feedback overall.

Renovation Work and a $300,000 Fundraising Push

Turning a century-old church into a kid-friendly cafe and play space isn't a simple build-out. The renovation requires work on the building's electrical and HVAC systems, along with soundproofing to accommodate a lively play area. Valley Community Development Corp. has provided business planning assistance to Grandison and Gray as they move the project forward.

To cover those costs, WillowRoot Collective is launching a capital campaign aiming to raise $300,000 through business sponsorships, grants and public fundraising. The campaign funds are intended to support costs including play-space and cafe equipment. The $300,000 campaign comes after the building's redevelopment history already included a far larger price tag: in October 2022, the Northampton City Council approved $500,000 in Community Preservation Act funding as part of a $4.6 million project that would have converted the then-6,200-square-foot church into 10 market-rate apartments, a plan that never came to fruition at the Hawley Street address. How much of WillowRoot's new fundraising goal has been secured so far has not been disclosed.