Dallas/ Crime & Emergencies

Organ Donor Group Sues Dallas Hospital to Keep Brain-Dead Woman on Life Support

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 21, 2026
Organ Donor Group Sues Dallas Hospital to Keep Brain-Dead Woman on Life SupportDallas County Court — Venue for Emergency Restraining Order
Google Street View

A Dallas-area transplant organization has taken a hospital to court, demanding it keep a brain-dead woman on a ventilator so her registered organ donation can move forward. Gift of Life Alliance sued Baylor Scott & White after the hospital said it would not proceed with donation from 38-year-old Emanise Timothee without a judge's order, even though the New York state woman had signed up as an organ donor years earlier.

The organization, formerly known as Southwest Transplant Alliance, filed an emergency request for a temporary restraining order in Dallas County Court on Thursday, according to CBS News Texas. The lawsuit says Timothee was declared dead by established medical neurological criteria at 2:10 p.m. on November 17 at Baylor University Medical Center in Dallas. Baylor reportedly told Gift of Life Alliance it would not allow the donation to proceed absent a court order, according to the same report.

A 2016 Decision in Buffalo

Court records cited in the lawsuit state that Timothee lived in Buffalo, New York, when she joined the state's Donate Life Registry in 2016, formally registering as an organ donor. According to the filing, she authorized donation of her heart, liver, lungs, kidneys, intestines, pancreas, skin, blood vessels, bone and connective tissue, corneas, and eyes for transplantation and research.

The suit argues that Texas law requires hospitals to assist with organ donations even when family members object, and that the Texas Revised Uniform Anatomical Gift Act bars anyone other than the donor from amending or revoking the gift unless otherwise stated. Gift of Life Alliance contends family consent is not legally required and that the family's objection has no legal effect, the lawsuit states. The organization also argues that each hour of delay threatens the medical viability of organs that could save multiple transplant recipients, per the filing.

Limited Comment While Case Proceeds

Gift of Life Alliance told reporters it could not provide further details because the litigation remains active. CBS News Texas said it reached out to both Baylor Scott & White and Gift of Life Alliance for comment and was unable to reach Timothee's family by Friday night.

The dispute echoes a case in Minnesota, where LifeSource sued Hennepin Healthcare, alleging staff refused to honor a deceased woman's organ-donation decision because her family objected, according to the Star Tribune. That lawsuit sought an order requiring the hospital to keep providing mechanical ventilation to preserve the woman's organs for recovery. LifeSource later dropped its suit after both the hospital and family dropped their opposition and the donation proceeded, the paper reported.

Other Families, Other Fights

Not every case plays out the same way. In New Jersey, the family of Keith Lott said he had removed himself from the state's donor registry after converting to Islam, believing he had withdrawn his consent, according to 6abc. His family said the New Jersey Sharing Network approached them shortly after his brain-death declaration and told them his organs would be harvested regardless. In a separate case described in the Transplant Journal, a federal court denied a family's request to block donation from a registered donor, and the recovery that followed resulted in four transplants, according to a case study published in the journal.

A System Under Strain and Scrutiny

The Timothee case lands amid a broader reckoning over how organ procurement works nationally. More than 109,000 Americans are waiting for a transplant, and about 12 die every day because of the organ shortage, according to HRSA data reported by NPR. The number of organs transplanted nationally rose to 42,048 in 2024, up 3.5% from the prior year, per federal data from the Scientific Registry of Transplant Recipients.

Policy around how organ procurement organizations interact with families is also shifting. New national guidelines will soon let procurement teams speak with families as soon as they begin considering ending life-sustaining care, a change NPR reports has drawn concern from critics worried that families may feel pressured. The same outlet notes that new policies are also meant to make it easier to pause organ retrieval if anyone becomes alarmed that something is amiss. Separately, the OPTN board approved the first phase of new national guidelines on Nov. 6 governing a technique called normothermic regional perfusion, set to take effect Dec. 6, which will require surgeons to cut holes in blood vessels as an added safeguard against blood reaching the brain. Critics argue the procedure, which restores circulation after a patient has been declared dead, undermines the dead donor rule that has long governed organ recovery.

For now, the core question in the Timothee case — whether a Dallas County judge will order Baylor Scott & White to keep her on a ventilator so the donation her family opposes can proceed — remains before the court, with no outcome yet reported.