
The Oshkosh Common Council voted unanimously this past Tuesday to direct city staff to begin terminating the agreements to buy the downtown City Center property for $12.5 million, ending a purchase plan that had been in the works for two years. The move leaves the future of the riverfront site uncertain, with tenants and city leaders now watching to see what happens next.
According to The Northwestern, council member Alec Lefeber said that after completing due diligence, the council concluded that proceeding with the acquisition would not be in the city's best interest. He pointed to residents' concerns about the city taking on a project of this cost, size and complexity, as well as the possibility that current tenants could be displaced. A formal resolution to officially end the purchase agreements is expected to come before the council at its next regularly scheduled meeting on Dec. 15.
The city had already put down $225,000 in earnest money on the deal, money it was set to recover since it opted out during the due-diligence period, the newspaper's report notes. Cost estimates for the project had grown substantially since the plan was first floated — back in May, Mayor Matt Mugerauer had estimated the price tag could climb closer to $30 million once demolition and tenant lease buyouts were factored in.
Small Business Owners Caught in the Middle
For Chanda Anderson, who owns Caramel Crisp inside City Center, the council's reversal stirred mixed emotions. She said she panicked when she first heard about the purchase plan two years ago, worried about what it could mean for her shop, but had also grown excited imagining what the city might build downtown. Now that the deal is off, Anderson said she was disappointed, adding that she plans to remain at Caramel Crisp for her customers as long as she can.
Paul Esslinger said a Plan B may involve the city helping in certain ways, though not in the same manner as the original purchase proposal. He said the details of any such plan are not currently available to the public. Meanwhile, Karl Buelow argued that redevelopment of City Center could substantially grow the city's tax base and said the project should still be pursued in some form.
What the City Hoped to Build
City planning documents had outlined ambitions far beyond a simple purchase. A city presentation described goals of developing a mix of housing, commercial space and public gathering areas on the site, framing the combined acquisition of the two parcels as a way to secure immediate site control while allowing for a phased redevelopment strategy over several years, according to the City of Oshkosh's own presentation. That same presentation placed the properties at roughly 16.526 acres combined, while The Northwestern's report described the City Center site as 17 acres — a discrepancy that remains unresolved in the public record.
Per WBAY, the city has said buying the property was meant to encourage private investment, expand the long-term tax base and activate vacant riverfront parcels, creating opportunities for housing, businesses, offices and public gathering space. The Greater Oshkosh Economic Development Corporation is now working with City Center to find investors on its own, and the organization told WBAY it is pursuing a private developer to lead redevelopment of the site.
GO-EDC Still Betting on a Public-Private Deal
Despite the council's about-face, GO-EDC struck an optimistic tone about what could still come together. The organization said it remains optimistic about the opportunity to bring a private developer to the table and create a more traditional public-private partnership, the station's report notes. Whatever redevelopment ultimately happens at City Center will now depend on the site's current owners rather than the city itself.
As Wisconsin Public Radio has reported, potential future uses floated for the property have included retail, housing, restaurants, office space and gathering space, but no official decisions on redevelopment have been made. The city's earlier timeline had envisioned acquiring the property in 2026 with a phased redevelopment strategy beginning in 2027 or later, per the city's own planning documents.
Open Records Request Underway
NBC26 has submitted an open records request for documents related to the City Center purchase and says it plans to share what it learns from that request as more information becomes available. For now, the city is stepping back from buying City Center altogether, leaving downtown Oshkosh's next chapter in the hands of whatever private partner, if any, eventually steps forward.









