
Three brand-new houses sit empty on Palatka's east side, paid for with a $2 million state housing grant, and nobody at City Hall can say who signed off on building them. Frustrated by the mystery, the Palatka City Commission voted unanimously on Nov. 12 to hire a firm to conduct a forensic audit of the city's handling of the Florida Department of Commerce grant.
The grant was awarded to the city on July 1, 2023, according to a report from the Palatka Daily News. Interim City Manager Cynthia Curry, who started with the city in June, told commissioners the money could go toward neighborhood home repairs, down-payment assistance and affordable-home development. But as staff dug into the project's history, they found three vacant, city-owned homes and two vacant lots tied to the grant, according to a separate report from citizenportal.ai.
Nobody Can Say Who Approved the Project
The houses, located at 1310 Washington St., 1312 Washington St. and 700 N. 17th St., have no residents, per the Palatka Daily News. City employees told commissioners they could not identify who approved the housing project in the first place. Marcia Carty was serving as city manager around the time construction likely began, but no evidence was presented at the Nov. 12 meeting showing that Carty approved it, and the city commission itself did not approve the construction.
Curry told commissioners the original housing contract called for the builder to develop just one home — not three. “My concern is that the grant administration side of this is problematic, quite frankly, in terms of how it rolled out,” Curry said at the meeting.
Houses Don't Match What Was Promised
Commissioner Will Jones said the homes were supposed to have three bedrooms and two bathrooms, but he personally saw that both Washington Street houses had only two bedrooms. Jones said he believes the homes do not fall within the affordable-housing range. “There's some things we have to go in and do a deeper dive, and I know that audit would provide that for us,” Jones said, adding later, “I think the forensic audit is the first thing we should do.”
The three completed houses received certificates of occupancy on June 30, according to meeting documents, but Curry confirmed they are not listed for sale. One of the homes was vandalized, costing the city $975 to repair, Curry said, though she noted the grantor will reimburse the city for that cost. The city also continues paying for utilities and lawn care at the unoccupied properties, though officials said at the Nov. 12 meeting that the total amount spent on upkeep was not yet known.
Vacant Lots Were Meant for Affordable Housing
Beyond the three houses, the city bought two vacant lots at 1406 and 1408 Washington St. on April 8, intending to use them for affordable housing. Neither lot currently has a house on it. Commissioner Justin Campbell said he wants the city to sell the homes rather than continue owning them. “I want the citizens to know that we were just as equally surprised when I received this information because we have made it unequivocally clear that we are not in the real estate business,” Campbell said.
Where the Grant Money Has Gone
According to meeting documents, the city has spent $673,350 on home repairs, $260,000 on down-payment assistance, and about $588,000 building the three houses and buying the two properties. That leaves roughly $478,000 of the grant still unspent, per city documents presented at the meeting. The city must use the grant funds by June 30, 2027, and staff plan to request an extension from the Florida Department of Commerce.
City staff also plan to approach the Palatka Public Housing Authority board first, asking whether it would like to purchase the vacant homes for affordable housing before pursuing other options, according to the citizenportal.ai report. The commission has directed staff to use the housing authority as the first line of negotiation for disposing of the three properties.
Grant Progress Reported Earlier This Year
The grant's broader rollout had shown signs of progress even as questions about the vacant homes emerged. A separate citizenportal.ai report on the CDBG-funded grant noted that staff and contractors had finished 12 home repairs and that the down-payment assistance program had helped 13 households. City staff told commissioners the grant was being used across four tasks, with home repairs and down-payment assistance in active delivery, and the city expected to complete at least 16 home repairs before June 30, 2026.









