
The Trader Joe's on Route 17 in Paramus has been crowned the busiest location in the country, according to a new study that estimated roughly 1.64 million visits to the store over the past year. The grocery chain's New Jersey outpost beat out a Manhattan location by about 22,000 visits, even as researchers acknowledged the race was closer than it looks on paper.
The ranking comes from The Greenest, which studied 550 Trader Joe's stores across 42 states and Washington, D.C., ranking the 25 busiest among them, with Paramus taking the top spot, as reported by News 12 New Jersey. The Greenest released its findings on November 12, and the estimates are based on third-party location data rather than official company figures, generally covering Nov. 1, 2025, through Oct. 31, 2026.
Exactly how many visits the Paramus store logged depends on which outlet's numbers you use. Patch reported the location on Route 17 had 1.64 million visits between Nov. 1 of last year and Halloween of this year, while Daily Voice put the figure at 1,625,619 visits over roughly the same stretch. Either way, that works out to about 4,491 visits a day the store was open — twice as many as a typical Trader Joe's, according to the study cited by Daily Voice.
When the Crowds Actually Show Up
The study pinpointed the Paramus store's single busiest hour as 4 p.m., when it averaged 583 visits, per the same analysis. Saturday, Patch's report notes, was the busiest shopping day of the week there. By comparison, the average store in the study logged about 806,118 visits a year, or roughly 2,227 a day — meaning the busiest stores in the ranking, Paramus included, drew at least 1.5 times the typical store's traffic.
Second place went to the Trader Joe's at 14th Street and Avenue A in Manhattan, which racked up about 1.6 million visits of its own. The Greenest cautioned that the Manhattan figure was adjusted and the gap is close enough that the Manhattan store could actually be busier than Paramus, a caveat researchers flagged directly in the findings reported by News 12 New Jersey. The next three spots in the top five all went to stores in California, per Patch's report.
Two Other Jersey Stores Make the Cut
Paramus wasn't the only Garden State location to crack the top 25. The Princeton store on Brunswick Pike came in at No. 17 with about 1.29 million visits and roughly 3,565 a day, while the Clifton location on Allwood Road ranked No. 19 with about 1.27 million visits and about 3,501 a day — bringing New Jersey's total representation in the ranking to three stores.
The ranking also had notable gaps: it excluded most New York City locations outside Manhattan, as well as stores in Philadelphia, because the data couldn't pinpoint them individually, according to the findings described by News 12 New Jersey. The Greenest's methodology relied on anonymized location data to estimate foot traffic, counting visits rather than purchases.
Why Paramus Draws a Crowd
Researchers attributed the crowds at the Paramus store to its status as a major retail hub, and the numbers back that up. The town has a population of roughly 27,000 people but is home to four malls, and The Greenest noted that the entire New York metro area effectively shops in Paramus, calling the town “a retail freak of nature.”
About 71% of Paramus Trader Joe's visitors also stopped at Westfield Garden State Plaza, and 47% of the store's customers traveled more than five miles to get there.
A Trader Joe's spokeswoman had no comment on the study, Patch reported, though she noted that the chain plans to open new stores next year in Jersey City, West Orange, Parsippany and Montvale.









