Oklahoma City/ Crime & Emergencies

Pardoned Oklahoma Fire Chief Seeks to Erase 5 Manslaughter Convictions

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 03, 2026
Pardoned Oklahoma Fire Chief Seeks to Erase 5 Manslaughter ConvictionsSource: James Johnson / Wikimedia Commons

A former rural Oklahoma fire chief who was pardoned by Gov. Kevin Stitt is now asking a judge to erase five first-degree manslaughter convictions tied to a 2010 drunken-driving crash that killed five of his friends. Prosecutors are fighting the request, filing a written objection that invokes the names of the victims.

Jordan Scott Powell’s petition, first reported by The Oklahoman, follows Stitt’s decision to pardon him for the convictions. Powell had led a rural fire department, according to the paper, before the crash upended his life and the lives of five families.

The case dates back to 2010, when Powell crashed his pickup truck while driving drunk. All five friends riding with him that day were killed, according to News9. Powell entered a blind plea of guilty to five counts of manslaughter in the case, KOCO reported at the time.

Conflicting Accounts of the Original Sentence

Exactly how much time Powell served remains murky, with two outlets reporting different figures. News9 reported that a judge initially sentenced Powell to five years before later reducing the sentence to 2.5 years and suspending the remaining 2.5 years. KOCO, however, reported that Powell received five years to serve behind bars with 20 years suspended, and that McClain County Judge Lori Watley ordered the suspended portion to run concurrent to his incarceration.

At sentencing, Roy Beason, whose daughter Trulie was among those killed in the wreck, pushed for the harshest outcome available under the law. “I want (Powell) to pay the maximum price that the law will allow. He owes us that,” Beason told KOCO. When News9 later reported that Powell’s sentence had been cut, Beason described the development in stark terms: “It’s kind of like a nightmare getting worse and worse and worse.”

How a Pardon Opens the Door to Expungement

Powell’s path to seeking expungement runs through a 2022 Oklahoma Supreme Court ruling that clarified how pardons interact with multiple convictions. In that case, the court found that state law allows a person to expunge all of their convictions once the governor has pardoned every one of them, citing the “plain, unambiguous text of 22 O.S. Supp. 2019 §18,” according to Justia. The court reversed and remanded a lower court’s denial of an expungement petition in that matter, which involved five drug convictions that had also been pardoned by Stitt, who issued the pardon on January 5, 2021.

That precedent did not involve Powell’s case directly, but it illustrates the legal mechanism now at play for anyone seeking to clear multiple pardoned convictions from their record in Oklahoma.

Prosecutors Push Back

Prosecutors have formally opposed Powell’s expungement request, filing a written objection that invokes the names of the victims killed in the crash, according to the Oklahoman’s reporting. The outlet did not detail the specific arguments laid out in that objection.

Even if a judge ultimately grants the expungement, the process isn’t instant. The Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation says that once it receives a certified copy of an expungement order, clearing court records typically takes about a month, with arrest-record expungements taking a similar amount of time after the agency receives the order and required fee. The agency also says it cannot pre-approve anyone for expungement ahead of a court ruling, according to its own guidance.