
Jeremy Thacker asked Phoenix for a simple set of records in September 2023: communications between Councilmember Laura Pastor and developers. He says he got nothing back — no documents, no response — for about 17 months, until he sued the city in March 2025 just to force its hand.
The 49-year-old Phoenix resident's fight finally produced a ruling in his favor. According to The Arizona Republic, Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Randall Warner found that Phoenix improperly delayed providing Thacker's requested public records and ruled the city must pay his attorney fees for failing to turn them over. Only after Thacker filed his lawsuit did Phoenix hand over more than 1,000 pages of documents, the newspaper reported.
Thacker's original concern was local: he wanted to understand how traffic and neighborhood association representation were being handled as Phoenix City Council moved to approve a 22-story high-rise on Central Avenue across from Steele Indian School Park, according to the same report. Pastor represents Thacker's district on the council.
A Judge Finds Delay, But Not Destruction
Warner's ruling wasn't a clean win for Thacker. The judge considered Phoenix officials' cooperation after the lawsuit was filed to be evidence of good faith, the Republic's reporting shows, and he ruled that automatic deletion of a councilwoman's text messages after a set period did not amount to destruction of records. Pastor's phone is configured to delete texts automatically after one year, per the same account.
That distinction matters because Arizona public records laws do not prohibit the automatic deletion of officials' text messages, the newspaper noted. Phoenix spokesperson Dan Wilson told the Republic that the city automatically deletes mayor and city councilmember emails after 90 days.
Still, Arizona law requires certain correspondence to be retained for varying periods depending on subject matter. The state's retention schedule, as described in the report, calls for lobbying records to be kept five years, non-historical correspondence between officials and the public, organizations, or businesses to be kept two years, and historical correspondence along with executive correspondence discussing policies to be kept permanently. Violating the state's records-retention law is classified as a class 2 misdemeanor, according to the same reporting.
Eneas Santiago, a former records specialist at the state library, told the Republic that automatic deletion of elected officials' digital correspondence is not best practice — though Warner's ruling found the practice itself didn't break the law in this instance.
Thacker Says the Fight Isn't Over
Thacker isn't satisfied. He believes Phoenix still owes him additional records and believes the city illegally deleted some of what he requested, per the Republic's reporting — beliefs that have not been established as court findings in the case so far. Warner, for his part, said Thacker should have continued requesting additional records if he believed documents were being withheld or destroyed, rather than assuming the worst.
“Public accountability almost seems imaginary,” Thacker said, according to the outlet's report. He didn't mince words about what it takes to push back against the city, either, telling the paper, “you have to be an idiot to try” to hold Phoenix accountable. He now plans to ask the judge for another trial, and says he'll appeal if that request is denied.
A Pattern Playing Out Statewide
Thacker's case lands amid a string of Arizona Supreme Court rulings reshaping how public records disputes get resolved statewide. In a September ruling involving a dispute between Matthew Abraham and the University of Arizona's governing board, the high court found that government entities that destroy a public record they know has been requested violate state law and can be held liable — including for a challenger's legal fees, according to KJZZ. But the same ruling underscored a structural gap: agencies only face consequences for noncompliance if they get sued, meaning, as the station put it, “It's only when a case goes to court that the agency can be forced to pay the challenger's costs.”
That leaves people who can't afford to sue potentially unable to access records they're entitled to, the court said, per KJZZ's reporting — a problem the justices indicated would require legislative action to fix. Separately, Courthouse News Service reported that the Arizona Supreme Court reversed an appeals court ruling that had allowed Phoenix to withhold police-union negotiation records, in a case the Goldwater Institute brought against the city back in 2022.
Phoenix has pushed back on the broader narrative that it stonewalls records requests. In earlier coverage from the Arizona Agenda, which reported that Thacker's records pursuit began while he was researching water use and costs at Phoenix's eight city-owned golf courses, city Communications Director Dan Wilson said most of Thacker's requests were fulfilled within 10 days and that the city had met its obligations under Arizona law.









